I know both games are up there with the greats, unfortunately I have yet to play both. Shadow of the Colussus is a pain to track down for a reasonable price and I havent gotten round to playing zelda Twilight princess  yet.

Which game is better in your honest opinion.

I am very intrigued to hear your opinions because I will be playing both games very soon, I know how many people love both games.

Thanks Megaman.2.

I don't think they even can or should be compared, I mean I played and loved both. some people said Sotc should have tried something like zelda and it "would have been a classic" if it did, infact the reason I like it so much is that it tried a different direction than Zelda and avoided being just a zelda clone with epic boss battles in between.


But if I have to choose I would say Sotc but just because of the music and atmosphere, other than that I can't tell which is better.

well 2 diff games.

both are good i so hope a sequel to collosus hits the ps3 some time.

twilight princess is neat as it lets you use the homebrew channel.

Good thing that you're planning on playing both.

Personally, I by far prefer The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, although it is cool that Shadow of the Colossus is something new. Great atmosphere and music in the game, but I think Twilight Princess is just very much the superior game, overall.

I loved Twilight Princess but I haven't played Shadow of the Colossus, although I have heard good things about it.

Shadow of the Colossus easily.

SOTC has a better story, and arguably better atmosphere although a bit dark.

define reasonable price? Its like a Greatest Hits going for under $20 new in NA.  Well I enjoyed SotC.  I cant say anything about Zelda tho.

Both AMAZING titles, neither can steer you wrong.

Both. Start with SotC since it is last gen. Then compare with TLZ TP. I will follow your comments about them