I'm well known on the site for my fair and balanced journalism, i've tried to be as fair and balanced as possible in my investigation of 'The greatest Game this Gen Thus Far'. I have incorporated in my investigation, the gamers feedback, critics concensus, influence and impact. I have asked the community for their short list of top 3 games this Gen, analysed the game collections of many respected members. I came to the conclusion and my research back this up, Metal Gear Solid 4 has hailed by Gamers and Critics alike as the greatest game this Generation thus far.

Every gamer I have spoken to has nothing but praise for the game, there has been no other game this generation that has reached the level of Metal Gear Solid 4 in terms of story telling and gameplay. It's impact and influence on the 'Gaming Industry' has been unparalleled, every game released after Msg4 have tried to continue it's legacy but ultimately failed.

Gamers Feedback

From Play.com - ( 446 customer ratings )

 The best game ever made? For some, certainly.

''Metal Gear Solid 4 is an exceptional game. That cannot be denied. This game has been created with the dedication and attention to detail that makes the greatest games what they are. You could play this game through ten times and not see all of the brilliant little touches, of which there are thousands. The core gameplay is better than it has ever been before, with a control system and gameplay mechanics that allow a wide variety of satisfying and effective tactics. There are many different ways to approach any one scenario, and you never feel as if you're forced into one being 'the best one'. This game can genuinely be played in many different ways, which is part of the triumph.''

CrazyJamie, Play.com customer/Gamer.

From Amazon.com -  (416)

PS3's killer app is here
''Hideo Kojima has done it again. MGS4 is the most detailed, convincing, and well-researched game I have ever played. It offers a compelling and imaginative glimpse into the future of high-tech warfare, a nuanced, intelligent storyline, vastly improved gameplay, and incredible graphics.''

Taki Renzaburo, Amazon.com consumer/gamer.

Critics Consensus, This is what some of my colleagues have said:

''Is it possible to give a game an 11? If so, this would be the game that would merit that score. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots is a title that exceeds all of the hype that was attached to the title.''

IGN - 10/10   

''For anyone who appreciates games that rise above the simple act of pushing a few buttons and pulling a few triggers, Metal Gear Solid 4 is a stimulating ride that you won't soon forget.''

Gamespot 10/10 

one of only 'nine games ever' to be awarded 40/40 by the japanes gaming magazine Famitsu.

The community seems to echoe my sentiment, I have asked some of the most well respected members VGchartz hast to offer for their opinion.

''I`m not MGS fan, but MGS game always was a masterpiece game. =) It`s just a High Quality AAA game, you may like it or not, but it still an AAA game.''

Crazzyman, Gaming analyst

''Mgs4 from start to finish is a spectacle that has been years in the making, once playing you fully appreciate the work that has been done on this masterpiece"

Carl2291, Gaming Historian

Mgs4 is a game that leaves gamers speechless, from its innovative gameplay to it's stellar graphics. Metal Gear Solid 4 is a game that all developers should aspire to make"

Skeeuk, Well respected VGchartz member.

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Konami

709,179

9.5

3.91m

14th Mar 09

The community can't get enough of the game.

Closing comment.

Will we see a game this Generation that will top Mgs4, My answer is can pigs fly?

"Many games have aspired to reach the stature of Metal Gear Solid 4, unfortunately many dont make it past the first hurdle"

Megaman.2., Vgchartz entertainer.

Greatest game this gen? You mean greatest game this Century

Reference

• http://www.play.com/Games/PlayStation3/4-/1022294/Metal-Gear-Solid-4-Guns-Of-The-Patriots/Product.html
• http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/metalgearsolid4gunsofthepatriots
• http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Famitsu#All_Time_Top_10_by_the_readers

Im a gaming historian

I like this thread...

Lots

Is there a yawn smiley?! Somehow I don't think somebody biased should announce greatest game of this generation.

Well said Megaman.

Keep up the good work.

I agree. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots is the best experience I've played this generation. An amazing conclusion to one of the best series ever.

But was the whole "heroic" introduction post really that necessary? My answer is can pigs fly.

Seece my favourite comedian where have you been hiding? I only post fair and balanced journalism.

to MANY GOOD GAMES

but yeah mgs4 is def @ the top

megaman2 , quality and quantity :D

its not easy blackstar