I agree with Super Paper Mario, while not nearly as good as the second, it was still a solid title. Another would have to be Mario Strikers Charged.

Review score wise, if I could up the score of any game it'd be Mario Kart Wii to about 90

Not exclusive I know but one of the best action games to come out this gen and one of the best super hero games in a long while.

Spider Man Web of Shadows, the simple fact that it looks great on the Wii and they made sure to give you the same experience as the HD consoles and is just an awesome game yet has been hit so hard by critics it's a shame :(

Opoona looks very interesting and one day I'll pick it up but from what I've seen it shouldn't be hit so hard.

Sonic Unleashed is flat out better on Wii and is just a fun game, sure it's short but it deserves to be treated better then people treat it and something true to the sonic series that everyone can play.

Star Wars TFU is also a lot of fun and to me better on the Wii, very few games do I deem better on Wii but it seriously is a blast to play with motion controls :\

That's just a few but there's plenty that gets bashed that shouldn't and plenty that doesn't get bashed but should.

Fire Emblem and Super Paper Mario.

Let's go right back to the beginning - Wii Sports (Metacritic average 76%)

76% for the biggest paradigm shift in gaming since the move to 3D? 76% for the defining game of this generation, the game that has sold more consoles than any other? Why? Because it dares to be a sports game without a litany of stats and modes, because it dares to be a sports game that, even although it's method of interaction is as close to the real thing as video games have come, isn't in any way a simulation. That's right, Wii Sports is a video game, not a simulator. It's not meant to be a simulation of its sports, it's meant to be a fun, video game facimile of them.

76%!!!!!!!! All the evidence I need to basically ignore almost all review sources for Wii games.

Wii Music!!

Also, whoever said Kororinpa deserves many congratulations. yay Gnac

Also Mario Kart, clearly the best Mario Kart game of all time, and yet it didn't get the scores it deserved

Excite Truck and Disaster: Day of Crisis.

EDIT: Oh snap, forgot all about Castlevania Judgment... Talk about a criminally underrated game. It's very fun, but critics decided to hate it long before release, and it got a horrid score...

It's gotta be Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn the game is just so good it deserves more praise and more sales.

And Dragon Ball Tenkaichi Budokai 3

For me based on fun value -

Tomb Raider Anniversary
Dewy's Adventure
Mercury Meltdown
Pinball Hall of Fame
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Double Agent (just got this dirt cheap and very impressed but it was massively overlooked)

Re: Kororinpa - FUN but WAY too short. At that length it should've been Wiiware or $20.
FE:PoR - LOVE it, but it really feels like a GC port (which really it is despite never appearing on GC). No IR support? And graphics could have been uped for Wii. Hopefully there's a true Wii FE sometime.
Deadly Creatures - Really? I got it, and while impressed with the effort just found the gameplay dull. Maybe that's just me.

Oops, I said I played CoD:WaW for 13 days online but it is really 6 days online.... Anyways, most these games people listed are good additions to the Wii library.

Castlevania Judgment.