Does it matter how long they are?

Just make them a decent length, you can't give enough detail if you make it too short

Can I know the Positive vs. negative feedback numbers for mine?

I reviewed Halo 3.

Awesome! You really are the man!

Nice job Talonman! Great work!

we should get paid for the reviews

Just posted my first review - Crackdown.

http://www.vgchartz.com/games/userreviewdisp.php?id=111

I accidently posted 2 so can a mod delete the dud one thanks.

do you guys think my reviews are too short?

Mine are pretty short, too. I don't think it's necessary to go into as much detail as a staff review.

I don't know if it's been talked about before (I mean, this thread IS 5 pages long), but would it be possible to make it so when people rate your review, they obligatory have to add a little comment, or tick a few boxes like in surveys?

Maybe we could create a list of things that could be "tickable", for example:
- Too long;
- Too short;
- Not informative enough;
- etc..

It would help us decide what we have to work on in our next reviews. I know some people don't take the time to comment on reviews, and that's not very helpful. :/