Many things.. Mainly though.. I want it to be the game that makes the industry stop in 2010 and wonder how nobody has been capable of making something like that.

I want it to be a console defining game along side Wii Sports and Mario Galaxy, because then we can be assured of feeling that awe and zelda magic at the surprises and pure genius that it will hold.

Perhaps I have my standards set too high but look at aLttP, Super Mario World, Mario 64, look at OoT, look at Mario Galaxy, these are the games that define Nintendo and nothing short of excellence will satisfy.

Graphics, I don't care what style they go for, music can be midi or orchestrated or both - The main thing is that they get it right and it pulls the player into the world of Zelda, just as Wind Waker did for me, I really believed that world was alive and that's something TP was sorely missing.

Seconded

Tp had so many items that were only useful on the dungeon you got them from like the ball and chain, dominions rod and that spinner one.

Motion plus(for sure), Balance board support(maybe)

As many dungeons as OOT with as many side quests as MM

2nd Playthrough mode with altered dungeons and quests

Lot of past zelda references

Actual role in the overall zelda story, rather than just random 'Link defeats ganon' scenario

Err... I though TP felt a lot more like a Zelda game than Wind Waker, and pulled me in a lot more too. TP was a game I played from beggining to end without stopping except for going to the bathroom. Wind waker was cartoonish and silly like mario, it felt like some pirate adventure rather than a zelda game. It didn't have the ambiance of OOT, MM, TP.

TP wasn't missing anything. The only thing wrong with it was it's short length, it's story was pretty lame.

Also, the fact that it was exactly the same as OOT or MM, just with better graphics, different temples, and a different story. Some of the visuals and puzzles were great though.

add techno music...(lol)

Motion+ with more precise sword combos. Harder boss battles (only place TP fell short). This is Nintendo, they make sure their top franchises are well taken care of.

I still want a futuristic Zelda...

1st. I want a Complete Remake of The Wind Waker on the Wii and 2nd. a real zelda for a wii with all the stuff " Wii motion Wii Balance, Wii Zapper, Wii Speaker, DSi Features wifi connection " I want everything the wii can provide it doesn't matter I'll wait for it I'll get armed by patience even more another two or three years but I want it a Zelda Game for the Wii just like were all :

The Legend of Zelda for the NES
The Legend of Zelda - A Link To The Past - for the SNES
he Legend of Zelda - Link's Awakenin - for the GB
The Legend of Zelda - Ocarina of Time - for the N64
and The Legend of Zelda - Twilight Princess - of course for the GameCube not the wii.