By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Does GTA have a place on Nintendo Platforms? (Article Which Echoes my Q)!!

Does GTA have a place on Nintendo Platforms?


 
We were all speculating on how well GTA: Chinatown Wars was going to do on the Nintendo DS when Nintendo announced it at last year’s E3. With the DS’s demographic skewed on the younger side of things with older adults as well as female gamers all getting in on the DS act, selling a mature rated game on that platform was always going to be a difficult task. But if any game was to overcome that obstacle, it would have been Grand Theft Auto. At least one would think, right? Chart Track has released their latest figures for the UK and no surprise really, GTA: Chinatown wars fails to break the top 5 and comes in at number 6. Not a bad position at any stretch of the imagination for a game, but this is GTA we are talking about, not just any game. So after all this, one must ask, does GTA have a place on Nintendo platforms?

It’s not like Chinatown wars received little marketing across the UK. Television ads, as well magazine covers and newspaper pull outs, were all displaying Chinatown Wars for the Nintendo DS. With the amount of DS’s sold in the UK, one would think that such a big title should perform better, but it goes to show what demographic really purchased DS’s. According to Chart Track, Chinatown wars shifted less than half of what Vice City Stories on the PSP did within its first week of sales. This demonstrates that the DS, although the much larger install base of the two, provides a strong challenge as to how to sell a “core” game to a demographic that prefers light hearted games, such as Layton or Brain Challenge. This also begs the question; would this have the same effect on the Wii? It could very well be so, considering that the highly rated and lets add very mature game, Madworld, only managed hit 27 in the top 40.

It seems very hard to sell a mature rated game on Nintendo platforms, not surprising really when all the adverts are about either Wii Fit or Brain challenge. It’s not hard to see who is buying Wii’s or DS’s, but it is a shame because Chinatown Wars is a great game and one that should be enjoyed by the masses. Sadly, it won’t be due to the fact the majority of people who own a DS will overlook it passing the usual anti-GTA remarks we have all come to hear over the years. With rumors of a GTA game on the Wii, included in our very own Rumor Killers, should Rockstar bother our instead concentrate on the platforms that sell millions of copies of GTA games? That’s for them to decide but selling GTA on Nintendo platforms seems harder than one thought.

____________________________

The ARTICLE raises some Serious questions

It has been said many times Nintendo's demographic now doesn't suit GTA....maybe they were right

but on GTA:DS we should wait to see how the legs pan out!

so do YOU think GTA has a place on Ninty Platforms?

______________________

_____________________



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Around the Network

Yes, Is only the first week and the people is saying that it is a flop? OMG



@MANUELF

it didn't have a great debut thats why



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

No, it doesn't raise any serious questions. It uses one area as a measure of success, much like Bruce on games did for Brawl.

Also, this is even worse, because it not only uses one area, it only uses one week.

Seriously, I'm like one inch from reporting you now. I just don't know for what.



@majin

seriously you want to report me for posting this?

seriously?!

Ps3 games get this treatement all the time.....its nothing new

GTA:DS debuted to less than half of PSP GTA's sales....on a much higher userbase

so this is a VALID question



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Around the Network

Breaking the top ten as a 3rd party game on a Nintendo system is a great debut. People seem to forget, on a weekly basis, that Nintendo game sales are not front loaded. This game will go on to have great sales, and all those who cried "fail" will once again have to pretend they never said so.



 

http://www.shanepeters.com/

http://shanepeters.deviantart.com/

Achievement is its own reward, pride only obscures.

HATING OPHELIA- Coming soon from Markosia Comics!

Honestly, can we please stop with these ridiculous industry stereotypes? It's beyond foolish to claim that Grand Theft Auto has no place on Nintendo platforms (whatever that means!) based on one day of sales of one game in one market!

While we're at it, do you want to claim that the 360 is the RROD machine, and the PS3 has "no games"? Just so we can be as obnoxious and misinformed as possible?



My Website

End of 2008 totals: Wii 42m, 360 24m, PS3 18.5m (made Jan. 4, 2008)

no, Ds/Wii games never stop at launch

this game will be huge....



don't mind my username, that was more than 10 years ago, I'm a different person now, amazing how people change ^_^

Guitar Hero on DS did not have a good first week in Others. Did anyone call it a bomb then?



MikeB predicts that the PS3 will sell about 140 million units by the end of 2016 and triple the amount of 360s in the long run.

@sulla

no-one claimed that

a question & claiming something are different....I hope you know that

I EVEN said in the OP....lets see how the legs are

jeez overreacting much



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey