| KylieDog said: Pretty sure Edge just gives low scores for the sake of publicity so they don't go out of business. Or maybe their review staff are just retards. |
Or maybe they just give fair scores because a 7 is NOT LOW.
| KylieDog said: Pretty sure Edge just gives low scores for the sake of publicity so they don't go out of business. Or maybe their review staff are just retards. |
Or maybe they just give fair scores because a 7 is NOT LOW.
how can we made them go broke?
COME ON it's 50 cent. >_
| Neos said: Finally a reviewer that knows how to score its games. Edge, +1 |
well, considering DoW2 deserves a 8-9/10 ... they dont know how to score a game ...
Time to Work !
i honestly wish edge would go bankrupt.they are so useless and inconsistence in their reviews that it's not even funny.
libellule said:
well, considering DoW2 deserves a 8-9/10 ... they dont know how to score a game ... |
They also gave The Witcher a 5/10, which was in my opinion easily the best RPG of 2007. However EDGE is one of the best magazines, if not the best, because they usually rate the games on a fair scale and do not seem to give favours to publishers.
| KylieDog said: Being harsh in reviews is fine, nothing wrong with that. Being inconsistant in reviews is really poor, and shouldn't be reviewing if like that. |
Opinions are inconsistent? Who would have known..
starcraft said:
Perhaps Spartan will make a thread...
|
Urgh, quit trolling.
With regard to a 7 for both RE5 and 50 Cent, I'm inclined to say "hey, it's Edge, what were you expecting?".
Resident Evil will sell regardless. I don't think going to be the AAA game that I hoped it would be, but I bet I'm going to enjoy it a lot.
I think that the gaming media is telling us what we want to hear, lately. If message boards say a game isn't an upper echelon title, then the scores are starting to reflect that. If we hype a game as the second coming of Jesus, Allah, and Buddha, we get scores that reflect that too.
KylieDog said:
When they come from the same source, in this case Edge, they should not be. |
So the Edge is ran by one guy? Or multiple people who have some kind of Borg hivemind?
I still don't get why these numbers are that big of a deal.
libellule said:
well, considering DoW2 deserves a 8-9/10 ... they dont know how to score a game ... |
That's why he said Edge+1. So Dawn of War II got an 8, so did Killzone 2 and RE5, MGS4 got a 9, and LBP got an 11.