I agree with Naznatips. And reviwers should compare the graphics of the game with what we have seen on the Wii thus far. Not comparing them with what games are looking on a 360 or a PS3.

I have never seen so much anger over reviews that haven't been written yet.

Personally, 1up's score of 2.5 out of 10 for Mario Galaxy is way more shocking!

stof said: I have never seen so much anger over reviews that haven't been written yet. Personally, 1up's score of 2.5 out of 10 for Mario Galaxy is way more shocking!

lol...jumping the gun a bit, huh.

stof said: I have never seen so much anger over reviews that haven't been written yet. Personally, 1up's score of 2.5 out of 10 for Mario Galaxy is way more shocking!

You should see Brawl. It got a -5/10. Apparently they felt Snake didn't have enough depth to his storyline in SSBB compared to MGS4.

ceres said: stof said: I have never seen so much anger over reviews that haven't been written yet. Personally, 1up's score of 2.5 out of 10 for Mario Galaxy is way more shocking! You should see Brawl. It got a -5/10. Apparently they felt Snake didn't have enough depth to his storyline in SSBB compared to MGS4.

I heard they also docked 2 points for him not having grey hair and a math teacher mustache.

naznatips said: What the heck is this 1UP preview? It's nothing to the plot of Halo 3 and Heavenly Sword? Halo 3 is The Covenant invading earth, after losing the best part of them: the Elites, they might as well change the name of The Covenant to "The Monkeys" because all that's left is the retarded brutes (who's AI has looked nothing short of ridiculous in the videos shown so far). Heavenly Sword is a terminally ill girl who decides to kill an evil emperor before she dies. That's the whole plot... Then, they say the graphics suck because it doesn't look like Bioshock, claiming it looks nearly identical to the Gamecube games (which it doesn't... not even close). How are you even going to compare Metroid Prime 3 to Bioshock? They are completely different games on completely different systems. Then, they claim the first area is a copy of Halo (I watched the full first hour, and it looks nothing like anything in Halo). The only redeeming factor in their review is at the end they say that they shouldn't judge the game on the first few hours... after spending an entire preview judging the game on the first few hours. I can't wait for 1UP to go out of business >_>

Ummmmm LAWL. But, what did you expect from 1up?

Naznatips: Yeah that's fair. Just because there are systems out that have better graphics we should dock all systems, even the ones showing the best graphics that they have shown so far. That's why all PS2 games were rated badly. Of course God of War 2 looks like complete shit compared to the 360 and PS3 games that were out when it was released. So lets knock it down to a 3. But that is always the case in the history of videogaming. They have always compared the visuals between consoles. I never have forgotten the discussion between the visuals of the genesis and snes with the game DOOM. PS2 is last generation .... If I say Wii is like last generation you guys get mad so be happy that people on sites don't see it like last gen and compare it to next gen consoles graphics and then you guys complain again. It is nintendo's choice to make a hardware that can't get the same visuals like X360 and PS3 :s.

Konnichiwa... How the hell did you make your post go all funny like that?

konnichiwa said: But that is always the case in the history of videogaming. They have always compared the visuals between consoles. I never have forgotten the discussion between the visuals of the genesis and snes with the game DOOM. PS2 is last generation .... If I say Wii is like last generation you guys get mad so be happy that people on sites don't see it like last gen and compare it to next gen consoles graphics and then you guys complain again. It is nintendo's choice to make a hardware that can't get the same visuals like X360 and PS3 :s.

There's a difference between comparing consoles of similar hardware on the exact same game versus taking games with no relation. Are we going to only rate PSP & DS games 1-5 out of 10 because they're so inferior to the Wii/360/PS3? Stof: it's an issue with the code being all wonky tonight. If you edit his post and remove the first set of /td /td /table code, it'll fix it. It's the 2nd time it's happened tonight and a mod was able to fix it the first time.

Stof says...Metroid Prime Completion count: 39% and climbing!

You're playing the game?