Speaks volumes about the composition of GameFAQs' userbase, it does

@Khan, ya that they actually have taste :P

Brawl deserved it
it's a really great game

That's great. Brawl is a great game so I think it deserved it.

Well, if you have followed the polls, SSBB trailed at the beginning before slowly catching up and overtaking MGS4. So, the Wii support has legs in GameFAQs, while the support for PS3/360 games are frontloaded!

but you analogy is fail because brawl doesn't have nearly as much legs as a lot of other nintendo games.

There's a wii game i'm never buying.

shocked it won game of the year, an update to a long running series with nothing new added to the gaming world.

if mkwii won i'd say the same thing.

(tho i love mkwii)

At the top, where it deserves to be...

^Technically neither did GTAIV or MGS4, they were just updates from their respective series, same with most other games that were either nominees or won GTOYs...

SSBB is great, even though you deny it :P
Although that's entirely an opinion.

Finally, some credit