Omg at first i was like its gonna be fun i mean the demo is good! ( Played demo like 2 hours ).
Then i got the game and ive made it like 2,5 hours threw the game still looking for the bi*ch Elena or what ever XD. But now having safely played and own both MGS4 and Uncharted on my PS3 and TV XD ( 32 ..tum/inch or what ever samsung ) MGS4 does have .. the edge on cutscenes.. How ever in gameplay Uncharted looks WAY TO SICK :O. Now i know what all ppl meant with the ''physics'' I dont think ive ever played a game like that! I thought MGS4 was sick becauase all stuff you could do! ( STILL THOUGH MGS4 GOTY AND MY BEST GAME EVER ) But Uncharted has the edge on graphics in gameplay (Not cut scenes xD) , and i like the physics theyre damn realistic!
So far the story is pretty fun! I needed an adventure like this i havent played one since ... I dont remmeber.. lol.
This gen its been pretty much shooting shooting , Sport games , (Thank god for Motorstorm and GT5:Prolouge they atleast started to put me in another direction then continue to shoot XD) and star wars TFU was to short.. but Hey im a SW fan i had to get it and i dont regreat it. Good story though.. And then... we got 2 of my best games i ever played MGS4 and LBP. MGS4 .. what can i say? Its my first MGS, Was so good i had to get 1-3 from ebay. The story was awesome!! I put starwars aside after i beat MGS4. Ive beaten it 16 times XD, And over 40 hours of MGO(Which is fun after a while when u understand the skills and all. CQC lvl 1 + blade 3 FTW! XD ). Compared to any game ive played MGS4 is the only one that deserve the name ' EPIC '. Then again i havent played alot of games that atm are big but this was just sick. LBP.. Just amazing :) I smile everytime i play the game. I laughed my head off when we played Assassins creed on LBP. A friend of mine couldnt get up he keept falling down, then grabbed a thing that took him back up and then he fell down again. I was litterly dieing. So damn fun!
Now Uncharted is on top 3. I love the story so far, And the relation with Elena and Nate XD. The graphics are sick i didnt think theyd be that good!! Gameplay is also sweet, Physics = PLAY B3YOND.
If i could rate it atm id give it a 10/10... No srsly! This is MY TYPE of game since 2005 all i did was play games like this. Then i went FPS >.< for like 2 years...
Anyway long story short =
Cutscene graphics = MGS4
Ingame graphics = Uncharted
Gameplay = MGS4 ( I feel you can do so much so MGS4 does actually win this )
Physics = Uncharted ( I liked how you moved in MGS4 but Uncharted .. wow )
Story = MGS4 ( Hands down.... i mean its to perfect IMO ).
Replay value = MGS4 ( This is a hard one but ive won MGS4 16 times i never spent that much time on any game.. Uncharted has trophies too and medals etc but i doubt i can play it 16 times ).
Fun factor = MGS4 ( I never get tired of stealth XD although maby LBP should be here.. meh lets make it a MGS4 - U ).
I basically shared my opinion of MGS4 and Uncharted. I saw alot of ppl discussing it before and this is my personal thought. Now i yet have to beat Uncharted fully to see if the fun factor changes and the story for that matter.
P.S. Vote for MGS4 = GotY!
OBS: Please dont hurt me.. i just shared my opinion :p!
(Former) Lead Moderator
