Gameplay is the most important thing.

I played a Tak game for DS, it was actually pretty fun but WAY too short. The mini games were a nice innovation. The platforming parts reminded me of good old n64 platformers, but there wasn't enough there to warrant a purchase.

yeah, gameplay has always held more importance then other categories for IGN.....

Here is my takeaway point

Presentation:
No widescreen support, ugly character models, and painful dialogue.

The first piece is an automatic Wii deduct.
The second piece is almost as automatic because the models will be uglier than the HD consoles by definition.
The third is something that could have been changed by the developer.

But basically there are some people who look to deduct any points they can from a Wii game. (And yes I fully realize both are Wii games on the same site -- but by different people).

Overall, both games have almost identical scores overall (from Gamerankings.com). Tak is 69.2 while Rygar is 70.0. Middling.

Mike from Morgantown