I notice two things here: first, there is a rising mantra among some of these editoralists. They claim the Wii is a sort of "Gateway drug," and that once these new gamers become real gamers, they will drop the Wii mote and move to where real games are, which is on the 360 and PS3, apparently. It's very difficult to discern the validity to that because it assumes something years into the future; another way to say: "Sometime, somewhere down the line, for reasons that we can't back with concrete data, in the unforseeable future, the Wii will lose."
But more improtantly, this "hardcore' mantra continues to surface. I'm just going to paste this back in here, because I believe it's quite appropriate:
I am so sick of the term 'hardcore'. It's a load of utter rubbish. I can't express properly the idiocy of continuing to use it in the context of games. GAMES!
It smacks more of the continued erosion of vocabulary of the general populace than it does the category of game being discussed.
Here's an idea. Instead of the age 12-35 male demographic calling itself 'hardcore' in some fervent hope that the games they're playing make them cooler, how about we call them 'bread and butter gamers'. That way, they'd know they're a major part of the industry, and have for many years been exploited by their supposed 'coolness' into buying a whole bunch of regurgitated, uninspired rubbish.
So I thank you all, bread and butter gamers. Thankyou for driving the industry forwards at such break-neck speeds that I've hardly been able to decide which sequel I'd rather play. Thankyou for bitching and moaning and whining about specs and hardcore games so much that both Sony and Microsoft haven't turned a profit on their latest products in their endeavours to please you. Thankyou for mocking those who are just becoming interested for the first time in our industry, thus showing what a wonderful sub-culture we've developed without them.
Grow up you little pukes. Be it Pokemon, Halo3, Bioshock, Little Kitty Island Adventure or Wii-Fit, more people gaming is a good thing, irrespective of what sort of game they're playing.