Super Mario Sunshine, or Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door.

If I am alone

1. SM Galaxy
2. SM 64
3. SM Bros 3

If i'm with other people

1. Mario Kart 64
2. SM Bros 3
3. Lucky Dip

some other things i have to take into account, does this desert island have a tv? does it have consoles and power outlets allowing me to play any of these games? component cables? :P

My favorite is SMW, with SMB3 as a close second and SM64 as third, but i'll take to the island New Super Mario Bros because is still fresh so i'll play it more times before boredom...

It would have to be Super Mario World, first videogame i owned.

super mario 64 on the ds! and a generator and some petrol so I can recharge that baby until I die from monkeys! you guys can just sit on the beach holding your game carts wishing you were more prepared!

i supose you could build something out of coconuts...

Super Mario All-Stars and Super Smash Bros Brawl are 2 of my top 10 videogames and my favorite games with Mario.