I've been wondering what WiiWare games were the best to download, but rather than start a new thread every week to ask the same question, I figured it'd be easier to just have one thread where we can pile up our personal WiiWare reviews for other members and guests to see what might appeal to them.
I'm hoping people will offer their own reviews of whatever titles they have purchased and will purchase in the future (even if the title is not from this week, but a game that's been out for a few months now). I also thought that having multiple people offer their opinions would be the best way to see which games are really worth it, and which are more narrow in their appeal.
I've included my four WiiWare games below: feel free to add your own critiques on those same games, or to add games that I don't have. I included pretty pictures: you don't have to. But please write out the full title, so people can find it quickly via control-F.
Strongbad's Cool Game for Attractive People (1000 Wii Points) offered a fairly amusing two hours of point-and-click goodness. The sense of humor was good, the controls were serviceable, and the puzzles weren't too twisted, so it was hard to get stumped for long. The game also offered a bunch of fun side-quests of sorts, such as finding extra costumes for Strongbad, or creating gruesome death scenes for the Teen Girl Squad (the latter was one of my favorite features in the game).
I'm a sucker for point and clicks, so I'll be downloading the rest of the series, but if you're not into the genre Strongbad doesn't have much to offer you.
Lost Winds (1000 Wii Points) is a beautiful 2D platformer with some excellent controls that can only be done with the Wii. So I wanted to fall in love with this game so very badly. Unfortunately, while I enjoyed the experience well enough I wasn't blown away by it. The game's difficulty was a breeze, there wasn't enough variety for my tastes, and while there was gusts of awesomeness sprinkled throughout the three hour game I mostly felt like I was just blustering through it.
Lost Winds was a relaxing game that has a ton of potential for the next segment, but I personally would spend my 100 points elsewhere.
Defend Your Castle is about as simple as you can get with a game. Use the IR pointer and A button to pick up an attacker, and fling him to his doom. Good times all around. It's a simple concept, and a simplistic game, but I've found that when I've got three friends over the game can become intense fun. Be prepared to get carpal tunnel, though...
It's a shallow experience that isn't too suited for single-players, but at 500 Wii Points Defend Your Castle is great as a multi-player experience.
So far the most expensive WiiWare title, Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles: My Life as a King has surprisingly proven to be my favorite game on the service so far. It certainly offers a twist on most RPGs; you're no longer the steadfast adventurer, you're the lazy king who sends the adventurers out to save his town for him. But the town and character management aspect of the game are mostly well done, allowing you to raise money and construct buildings to support your fledgling adventurers on their various quests.
Mind you, the game has some serious flaws: the morale system is a major drag, and this game will try to nickel-and-dime you via DLC like no other. Still, if you're the type of player who enjoyed Act Raiser or the Tycoon series, this game will more than justify its 1500 Wii Points price tag.