By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - David Jaffe wants dev names on box covers, says Miyamoto isn’t as big as Spielberg because of it

http://gonintendo.com/?p=52629

David Jaffe wants dev names on box covers, says Miyamoto isn’t as big as Spielberg because of it

Alot of the net posters commenting on this story are assuming game devs who want this treatment are ego maniacs. They then go on to say that movie stars and movie directors are ok to ask for it because that’s just how it is, but game makers are a–holes if they as for such treatment. To these folks I say: go f— yourself. The movie folks negotiated for those credits and fought tooth and nail for them. They were not just given them by the movie gods or the kind folks who run the movie studios or the movie going public. So don’t accuse us of being arrogant just because some of us would like to be treated with as much re$pect (be it money or credit, and preferably both) as we can get away with. Plus, granted Miyamoto and Wright are not as big of names as Spielberg. BUT THAT IS BECAUSE MIYAMOTO AND WRIGHT DON’T HAVE NAMES ABOVE PRODUCTS and they don’t have ability to negotiate for the sort of press treatment and PR perks that movie folks get (which, in turn, turns them into brand names). - David Jaffe, Eat, Sleep, Play

That’s a very interesting point. Do you think Miyamoto would be an even bigger gaming celebrity if Nintendo plastered his name on the front of boxes? I mean, plenty of people buy games today because they know Miyamoto is involved. I wonder if there would be an even bigger impact if Miyamoto’s name was always on the cover. Hell, I’d just like to see that happen one day. The man has worked his ass off, creating Nintendo’s biggest and best characters. Don’t you think he’s earned a spot on the cover?

More thoughts from Mr. Jaffe here

 



tag:"reviews only matter for the real hardcore gamer"

Around the Network

Hmm... I wouldn't mind it. Sid Meier does it for the Civilization games right. They could put the top 3 workers of the game on the back, or not too big in the front. With somebody like Shigeru Miyamoto, you don't know how much work he put into the project, he might not have been the leader. However, putting it at the beginning of the game (before the cutscenes and intros) would be good as well.

"Shigeru Miyamoto & Cliffy B Present: Gears of Wario"- something like that.



Leatherhat on July 6th, 2012 3pm. Vita sales:"3 mil for COD 2 mil for AC. Maybe more. "  thehusbo on July 6th, 2012 5pm. Vita sales:"5 mil for COD 2.2 mil for AC."

David Jaffe is nothing more than an attention whore.

So his name (or Miyamoto's) should be placed on the cover but screw the other 50-100 people that put in just as much work on the game? Their name is perfectly fine sitting in the credits.



Oh god this could turn bad, "From the makers of Ninjabread Man 3 comes..." bad.

Not a bad idea though. The only problem is that a lot of studios don't have that 1 big public guy like Miyamoto or Wright. It would only apply to a few devs anyway.



the games would probably also sell more with miyamotos name



tag:"reviews only matter for the real hardcore gamer"

Around the Network

@twestern - What about the 100's of people who help in movies. Its the same thing. The main person who essentially "created" the game deserves to have their name on the box.



superchunk said:
@twestern - What about the 100's of people who help in movies. Its the same thing. The main person who essentially "created" the game deserves to have their name on the box.

 

Who said I liked having the directors name plastered all over a movie?

Also, movies and games are different.  With a movie, I care who the various actors are and I want to know who they are.  For the most part, I don't always care about whose name is on a game.



That's a good idea.

"Shigeru Miyamoto presents Mario Mario in

SUPER MARIO GALAXY"



Could I trouble you for some maple syrup to go with the plate of roffles you just served up?

Tag, courtesy of fkusumot: "Why do most of the PS3 fanboys have avatars that looks totally pissed?"
"Ok, girl's trapped in the elevator, and the power's off.  I swear, if a zombie comes around the next corner..."

The credits at the beginning of movies and television shows are a nuisance. They serve no function beyond a plot by guilds to elevate their members. The reality is they are not in the least effective, and more to the point alienate the audience. The overwhelming majority of movie goers despise them as their precious time being wasted by pretentious pricks. Nobody likes them, and nobody pays them any attention. In fact this is one more inconvenience keeping the public out of movie theaters, and more then happy to see a movie on DVD where they can disc skip past the stupidity.

Anyone claiming that this antiquated practice can help to gain anyone respect does not understand the meaning of the word. Respect is earned through how you conduct yourself and what you provide. When you deliver a magnificent product consumers make it a point to learn your name. Games are not movies you have instant access to this information it is called the manual. Find me a movie that actually lists the names of those involved in a hard form.

David Jaffe is just being a self serving prick. He wants a cult of personality more then he wants sincere recognition. The reason he wants this is because he wants to parlay a couple success into the right to make millions of dollars with just a name. The industry does not need this, and neither does Hollywood for that matter. This is part of what is going wrong in Hollywood, and this is why their products are suffering for it. The name in Hollywood is what is important not the concept or the art.



twesterm said:
David Jaffe is nothing more than an attention whore.

So his name (or Miyamoto's) should be placed on the cover but screw the other 50-100 people that put in just as much work on the game? Their name is perfectly fine sitting in the credits.

 

I see no problem in it, I'm sure there would be the potential benefit for the consumer.

"hey "X" made this game, he made this other game that I absolutely loved, so maybe I'll give this one a try"

It's the same with movies, I always looked at who directed it and who wrote, that will usually tell me if the movie will be worth my while.