RB2 gets my vote.

Guitar Hero guitars have always been far better than Rock Bands. I expect this time to be no different. I believe Guitar Hero's drums will better or at the least, as good as the Rock Band drums.

Rock Band's guitar was a piece of trash. May it live it's life encased in feces.  The drum's also have some poor hit detection on fast parts.

Rock Band guitars have always been far better than Guitar Heros. I expect this time to be no different. I believe Rock Bands drums will better or at the least, as good as the Guitar Hero drums.

Guitar Heros guitar was a piece of trash. May it live it's life encased in feces. The drum's also have some poor hit detection on fast parts.

Fixed.

Sorry kn, that's just wrong... No offense. o_O

Did you ever try to play the Rock Band drums with a not working pedal because it's so weak, it breaks the second you try to move up from Medium to Hard? I don't know, I wasn't doing it the wrong way either.

Guitar hero all the way.

guitar hero looks more interesting...

Lol, none taken.  I always wanted to do that.   I actually greatly prefer the RB guitars over the GH guitars.  Perhaps it is because I only dabbled with GH before Rock Band came along.  I decided to give GH a try after many hours on RB and absolutely hated the GH guitars.  So there you go.  My opinion.  I'm quite sure it stinks.

The Rock Band guitar was awful. Interesting features, but terrible execution.

@ kn:

Well, I prefer Rock Band instruments for Rock Band, but trying to play Guitar Hero: Aerosmith with the RB guitar just doesn't work at all for me. I don't know, probably not used to it (compared to GH guitars on RB, which work quite decently until the big rock endings).

I just prefer the strum sound compared to the button sound. It just messes me up on songs like ''Still Alive.''

As a Wii only owner, I like the GH guitar much better than the RB guitar. In fact, I just ordered another GH guitar as part of todays GH Aerosmith Gold Box deal.