best one of the 3. A solid 8.5/10

i would give it 5/10, E3 as a whole sucked in my opinion

just as bad as nintendo's, 5/10

best of the 3 sans FF13 bombshelll

Nintendo's was bad and sony was........well it was better than nintendos..lol

Some nice announcements like MAG, Quest for Booty (I was worried this would be a dumb minigame/spinoff thing), and Resistance Retribution. Also did anyone notice Valkyria Chronicles on the PSP?

Overall I'd say Microsoft won. They had the FF13 bombshell and showed a lot of real gameplay. Sony was decent. Mostly just trailers, but some really cool things like MAG. Still, it's all just promises, and we've had a lot of those from Sony. Seriously, start releasing some games. And Nintendo's was the worst by far. I didn't see it, but not one bit of what they talked about interested me.

This E3 was pretty awful though.

9.0/10.0

I enjoyed it a lot almost all of the games they showed were amazing. The two things that take away .5 are:

- God of War III lame trailer
- No new rpg exclusives announced

B+ for production values.

Quality of presentation was better than microsoft but the content definately wasn't...I got for gameplay over graphics...as they say ;)