Boring 2/10 AC, wii speak, and motionplus were intresting. Everything else was boring. No core ninty franchises either. And they saved the big flashy ending for WiiMusic, I was like, WTF.

4/10 terrible nothing good or new, really disappointed no hardcore game, what happend with Kid Ikarus.
I think nintendo forgot about us, gamers and is focusing on nongamers triying to get them to be gamers so they can forget about them too.

Unless your a 360 only owner who loves Final Fantasy, in which case it's probably the best E3 that can ever occour.

D

On the one hand... it sucked.

On the otherhand... i can't deny that the swordfighting did look awesome.

Really seems like it's going to not know until we see if Wii motion plus catches on or just isn't used.

I say 4/10.

For the actual buisness people... I'm sure it'll "win" but as for fans... eh...

So new Mario and Zelda for Wii though eh?  I guess they announced it?  Reggie just said they did?  I must of missed it.

C

A very boring show to watch but did have a lot of solid and new announcements for gaming which was somehting MS lacked in theres. But doesn't get higher than what I rated MS because nothing really huge.

so far both MS and Ninty's have been solid but in different ways. But none of them extremely spectacular yet. Really won't take Sony too much to top it just need to have the consistency of MS's presentation tied in with the new stuff Ninty had.

1/10

nintendo completely disappointed me, were are the games?

3/10

I think it delivered on the hardware front with voice chat and 1:1 motion controls. Fanboys have been hating on the Wii using those talking points for a while. Where Nintendo failed to deliver was in the software department. One big title like Zelda, Icarus, or Punchout or any kind of surprise announcement would have done wonders for that conference.

5/10...

I really don't like that new Woman (did any one catch the "Welcome me in joining")

Needed more NEW game announcements