By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Metacritic: GTA vs Zelda fanboy wars

Pinkie_pie said:
Mano777 said:

If you filter the profiles of most people who gave GTA a zero, coincidentally they also gave a 10 to Zelda or some other Nintendo game—lol. I never imagined GTA would cause such a meltdown.

These Nintendo fans are unbelievable. As soon as they saw GTA 6 surpasses OoT they had to review bomb GTA 6. GTA fans didn't care about OoT's score and let it be when it launched.  In fact they were happy for Oot's score 

There were GTA fans review bombing Ocarina and leaving reviews saying "bad game, GTA is better" before GTA6 even released, don't act like this is a one-sided feud. 

Last edited by curl-6 - 15 hours ago

Around the Network
curl-6 said:
Pinkie_pie said:

These Nintendo fans are unbelievable. As soon as they saw GTA 6 surpasses OoT they had to review bomb GTA 6. GTA fans didn't care about OoT's score and let it be when it launched.  In fact they were happy for Oot's score 

GTA fans were review bombing Ocarina and leaving reviews saying "bad game, GTA is better" before GTA6 even released, don't act like this is a one-sided feud.

That's only a select few. Not review bombing it's why OoT's users score was in the high 90s. GTA fanbase is massive if they review bombing OoT when it released OoT score would be very low



Pinkie_pie said:
curl-6 said:

GTA fans were review bombing Ocarina and leaving reviews saying "bad game, GTA is better" before GTA6 even released, don't act like this is a one-sided feud.

That's only a select few. Not review bombing it's why OoT's users score was in the high 90s. GTA fanbase is massive if they review bombing OoT when it released OoT score would be very low

Only like 0.001% of any fanbase is obsessive enough to bother with review bombing.

GTA's user score isn't as low as it is because of Zelda fans, it's primarily being bombed by culture warriors, trolls and contrarians.



Pinkie_pie said:
curl-6 said:

GTA fans were review bombing Ocarina and leaving reviews saying "bad game, GTA is better" before GTA6 even released, don't act like this is a one-sided feud.

That's only a select few. Not review bombing it's why OoT's users score was in the high 90s. GTA fanbase is massive if they review bombing OoT when it released OoT score would be very low

That’s fair but it’s also fair to point out that GTA’s reach and fan base is far greater than OOT’s and I genuinely don’t believe this is mostly down to Zelda fans downvoting the game as conversely the Zelda fan base is not large enough to dent GTA on its own. It seems to me more like very angry children and the comments themselves tell us as much when they complain about “woke” or “simp” etc - I think there have been bad actors from both fanbases but again this isn’t purely down to people from the Zelda fanbase downvoting the game. We can say it’s a lot of disgruntled GTA fans downvoting Zelda because it’s been 9.6 until literally last night - even if it was tit for tat, Zelda doesn’t have the same numbers of reviews as GTA, so unless people also want to claim that these Zelda fans are so committed they are making extra metacritic profiles to attack GTA, there is a lot more going on here. I’m not defending or blaming anyone btw, I’m basing this on actual comments that anybody can view and also on numbers.

Last edited by Majora - 15 hours ago

I think metacritic removes malicious reviews. Though its so stupid and immature to be review bombing games like this. Both GTA and Zelda had 99 critic scores. Couldn't they just be happy with that?



Around the Network

To be clear, this is a tiny minority of bad actors on both sides.

99.999% of Zelda fans and 99.999% of GTA fans couldn't care less about this and are busy enjoying their game of choice.



curl-6 said:
Pinkie_pie said:

That's only a select few. Not review bombing it's why OoT's users score was in the high 90s. GTA fanbase is massive if they review bombing OoT when it released OoT score would be very low

Only like 0.001% of any fanbase is obsessive enough to bother with review bombing.

GTA's user score isn't as low as it is because of Zelda fans, it's primarily being bombed by culture warriors, trolls and contrarians.

Why didn't we have those culture warriors and trolls for Oot's review? Like I said OoT users score was at 96 and there was no mention of it being review bombed. The majority of the GTA 6 bombed are probably Nintendo's fans not happy it surpasses OoT or it's not releasing on Switch 2



Pinkie_pie said:
curl-6 said:

Only like 0.001% of any fanbase is obsessive enough to bother with review bombing.

GTA's user score isn't as low as it is because of Zelda fans, it's primarily being bombed by culture warriors, trolls and contrarians.

Why didn't we have those culture warriors and trolls for Oot's review? Like I said OoT users score was at 96 and there was no mention of it being review bombed. The majority of the GTA 6 bombed are probably Nintendo's fans not happy it surpasses OoT or it's not releasing on Switch 2

Do you have any actual evidence that it's mostly Zelda fans doing this?

As for why GTA drew the ire of culture warriors more than Zelda, that should be obvious, as a game that deals with realworld politics via its satire of America, GTA is obviously going to draw more fire from culture warriors than a fantasy game that has nothing to do with the real world.



Pinkie_pie said:
curl-6 said:

Only like 0.001% of any fanbase is obsessive enough to bother with review bombing.

GTA's user score isn't as low as it is because of Zelda fans, it's primarily being bombed by culture warriors, trolls and contrarians.

Why didn't we have those culture warriors and trolls for Oot's review? Like I said OoT users score was at 96 and there was no mention of it being review bombed. The majority of the GTA 6 bombed are probably Nintendo's fans not happy it surpasses OoT or it's not releasing on Switch 2

Why would culture warriors come after OOT? I've seen a lot of the usual culture war types coming after GTA 6 already, so imagine most of it is them.



Pinkie_pie said:
curl-6 said:

Only like 0.001% of any fanbase is obsessive enough to bother with review bombing.

GTA's user score isn't as low as it is because of Zelda fans, it's primarily being bombed by culture warriors, trolls and contrarians.

Why didn't we have those culture warriors and trolls for Oot's review? Like I said OoT users score was at 96 and there was no mention of it being review bombed. The majority of the GTA 6 bombed are probably Nintendo's fans not happy it surpasses OoT or it's not releasing on Switch 2

No the majority of bad reviews for GTA 6 are not frustrated Zelda fans... GTA has almost double the user reviews of OoT, the bad reviews are coming from frustrated frat bros who are disappointed that they can't go and cheat prostitutes out of paying them and beating them with a baseball bat, while they have to paint their house and build furniture for their girlfriend.
GTA 6 has altered the gameplay in a way, that not everybody is gonna like, so naturally some players are gonna be disappointed.