Saw a lot of negativity about Marathon and it was actually funny to see, first because of how many ways people are going to talk shit just to not say their real problem with the game it's that it's a Sony game and second because a lot of that people also talked shit about Helldivers and a couple months later they were asking for a port, bragging about the game selling most on PC or talking about how AH isn't a PS studio just to cope with the fact that Helldivers has been a PS IP since before 2015. I can totally see the same situation happening when Marathon releases, "My system saved that game", "Bungie isn't a PS Studio" lol.
Personally once I knew what they were going to show was part of the ALPHA I adjusted my expectations and thanks to that I was able to see that the game is actually very promising but there's a lot of work left. Actually I wouldn't be surprised if what they showed is actually older than the status of the game right now but they decided to show it anyway because it was stable.
The article that was quoted to talk about the price was so fucked up lol. I read the whole thing and it was pretty clear it was made by some entitled guy. You can't call yourself a fan of someone and then start slamming their new work just because it doesn't fit with you.
Until the game opens for preorders we won't know the situation on PS so for now we only have what we can see in SteamDB and right now the game has better numbers than Concord never had before release so I don't expect for it to "flop", actually for a game that showed almost nothing the game has good numbers. Once they show more in the Summer event thing (and oh boy there is a lot they didn't show), they say the real price of the game ($40) and they announce the beta I'm pretty confident the data will be even better.
I think the worst part of this situation is the release date, I don't give a damn about Borderlands but PlayStation has the rights of Borderlands marketing and that means a high probability that Marathon won't get marketing under the PS brand, people can say what they want but PS marketing is one of their strongest points and a reason why a lot of games are actually successful. That is smart and stupid at the same time, it's smart because if both games hit big then Sony has one of their biggest months yet but it's stupid because you are literally competing with yourself, the advantages that Marathon has over Borderlans is the fact that it is a competitive shooter and also the price, two main points when it comes to shooters. We will never know who was the one with the idea, I can see both parties making the decision, Bungie's CEO is what's left of a terrible administration pre acquisition and Sony probably putting a dead line to Bungie to release the game, that deadline being 2025 before GTA6 release. We know Borderlands will have a "healthy" separation from GTA6 release so we know the release window is end of October-November. This is also important because it also means if Sony wants to release something else this year it has to be at end of August max.
Anyway I have been ready for people to call Marathon a flop for a long time lol, extraction shooters are niche in comparison with other online shooters so if Bungie and Sony are smart their first goal has to be getting similar player numbers to what Hunt has right now and I believe that's doable.