are you serious?? why do you say GTA IV is overrated??
it's the most perfect game that exists and it has everything perfect, if IGN says it's perfect, then it's perfect!! :p

Halo 3 is overrated, its a good game, but i dont think its that much better than Halo 2.

Super Mario Galaxy

GTA IV

Zelda 64

Orange Box

Funny discussions going on in this thread :D

For me:
Not a single game, but in my opinion the whole FPS genre is ridiculously overrated by western media since the day Doom was released.

And it doesn´t seem to ever stop. I´ve got the feeling that every, absolutely every single FPS gets a rdiculous amount of previews, early hands-ons, hands‘n‘feet-ons, forum threads and inflated review scores from media and dedicated genre fans.

But that´s just me. Maybe I just hate that genre so much because people´s FPS love gave the adventure genre in USA a headshot in the late 90s & the WRPG genre got severely injured as well (and is still on convalescence).

Resident Evil 4 - I hate the controls.

I also think that NSMB is somewhat overrated. The 2d classics were better.

Metal Gear Solid, slow and boring..


World Of Warcraft same reason as above....

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Metal Gear Solid 2.

I just didn't enjoy it like i did with the others.

Every Halo game

Final Fantasy 7

Mario 64

Every Resident Evil before 4

Soul Calibur 2

Street Fighter 2

Every Mortal Kombat

Killer Instinct

Halo 2, 3
World of Warcraft
Resistence:Fall of Man
Super Mario Glaxy
Bioshock
Gears of War