So Spectre was on TV last night and it reminded me of this thread, so I watched it for the purpose of posting here.
I think there's a lot to like, initially at least. The pre-title sequence is really good, and the pacing and mood of the first half / two thirds or so is spot on. It takes a little while to come together, and I think there's a desolation to some of the shots and scenes that is really effective. OHMSS throwback is nice.
Then after the train scene, it all goes to pot. Off the top of my head, I can't think of a worse plot point in the series than tying Bond to Blofeld in the way that they do. An abysmal contrivance. Swann is also now in love with Bond after about three days, although I can let that slide as that's the sort of thing that happens in this universe. Then we have the finale in London, which just seems to drag on.
Torn on a score here, as it starts off so well. I'll go for a 4, as it really falls to pieces towards the end. Also, the theme song is poor.