Hey OP, could you add Opencritic to it? Metacritic unfairly weights the scores of certain outlets. Opencritic includes sites like vgchartz, and certain youtubers. They aren't included in the official score, but they do get included in the percentage of critics that recommend the game.
Edit: Well shit, something is wrong with Opencritic right now. They aren't displaying the scores.
I added Opencritic.
Current Metacritic score 89 based on 48 critics
Current Opencritic score 89 based on 45 critics