DonFerrari said:
Runa216 said:
Honestly? Dark Souls III was by far the most challenging, followed by Dark Souls I and II. Demon's Souls wasn't too bad (It's easily the shortest of the games), but Bloodborne and Sekiro were both pretty damn easy, all things considered. |
You are used to the gameplay, so possibly your hardest time on the platinums were stuff that doesn't come through natural game progression. |
Oh yeah, some of the trophies were maddening to get for many reasons. Mostly just the spells, miracles, pyromancies, and rings.
With rings, you HAD to get to the end of the game on NG+2 because many of the rings only spawned in NG+2 and one of those rings could only be found after the Nameless King boss fight (So basically, you gotta fight the toughest boss in the main game on NG+2). Most of the rings were fine, but this forces you to go through the game nearly 3 times without exception.
With the spells, miracles, and pyromancies, there were some insane requirements for time and dedication. I think you can get either the Spells or Pyromances just on your first playthrough, but so many of the other magic-related collectibles put you on quest lines that locked other questlines out or made it impossible to get all the spells. Like, for example, if you did the Rosasia's Fingers covenant...you locked yourself out of some healer's questline that gives you miracles...but you need to do Rosasia's Fingers to get a spell.
Likewise, you have to do a bunch of shit for the 13 covenants, and some of them take forever. Each covenant has a special item you use to raise your allegiance to that covenant, and some covenants you have to get 10 items, other covenants you need 30 (Again, each one of these is a single spell out of like 30 or 40 needed for ONE trophy). Each of these items has 2 methods to get it, either do PVP/PVE online stuff, or grind. A lot. Like just getting Pale Fingers took me like 12-15 hours. That's The time it took me to get ONE spell, for ONE covenant, for ONE trophy. I probably spent 12-15 hours just going on a loop in Anor Londo, farming the silver knights will ALL the discovery-raising spells and equipment.
So yeah, it wasn't HARD, persay, but it was definitely time consuming and required a whole lot of prep time and planning to not lock yourself out of missable trophies and spells.
Bristow9091 said:
I'm pretty close to the Dark Souls Remastered and Dark Souls 2 platinum trophies. For the first I just need to get all the unique items and upgrade all the elemental weapons, which can be gotten by drop trading online anyway, and for the second I just need a couple more spells, which I can do by rushing through NG+ and halfway into NG++ for an NPC to sell them to me... I just can't be arsed doing either lol. |
I honestly wouldn't bother with Dark Souls II unless you plan on farming The Rotten 12 times with bonfire ascetics. You can skip like 75% of the game and jump right to drangleic if you make it to The Rotten and just farm like 3 million souls. My NG+2 run took me about three hours to get that final spell, which like in Dark Souls III can only be accomplished on NG+2. I didn't like Dark Souls II, so take my opinion on it with a grain of salt.
Dark Souls I is funny because I found it a lot of work, but I pretty much did all that stuff naturally as I was exploring and trying new things. Took a lot of work but shockingly I already had like 90% of the required items when I started seeking out the details. I think Dark Souls Remastered would have been more of a challenge or time consuming had I not accidentally did most of that trophy in particular before hunting for it.
My Console Library:
PS5, Switch, XSX
PS4, PS3, PS2, PS1, WiiU, Wii, GCN, N64 SNES, XBO, 360
3DS, DS, GBA, Vita, PSP, Android