Nautilus said:
spemanig said:
It obviously would have sold less, Zelda is a massive killer app, but it still would have sold a lot without it. Like you said, the concept and execution was there. Zelda was just the gateway, but it could have been a much smaller franchise like F-Zero or something, and it would have still done exceptionally at launch. Same with the PS4. At launch, there weren't a lot of worthwhile games, but people wanted PS4's, so they just dealt with it. Same with the 360.
Most people at launch didn't buy the Switch because they wanted to play Zelda. They wanted to play on the Switch, and got to play Zelda because of it. IMO, if you're buying the Switch in the first 6 months, you just want a Switch, and are using whatever game you get as an excuse to get one. It's not exactly bursting with software yet.
|
Depends on what you consider a lot.If it didnt have a game of the same (or close) caliber like BOTW, it would still have sold well, but I dont think it would have reached Nintendo sales expectations.
And your comparison with the PS4 is wrong.While the hardware itself was desirable, it compensated the lack of a high quality game or games with sheer quantity.Switch didnt had this, but it wasnt a problem because it had that one extremely high quality game.And people bought the Switch because it was a desirable product AND it had a desirable game.A gaming device sells based on its software.If it didnt have games worth buying for, it wouldnt have sold this well.The same can be said with the hardware.If it has a horrible design behind it, people will be hesitant to buy it.See Wii U as a clear example of it.In the end, it had excellent games, but since the hardware itself was faulty, it didnt do well.For the software side, look at the 3DS.The 3DS was( at the very least at the time) a compelling piece of hardware, but since it launched with shitty software, it sales only picked up when compelling software appeared(3D Land and Mario Kart 7, if Im not mistaken).
Its not a either this or that scenario.The videogame industry, in this regard, is very different from everything else.You cant have a 0 on one side(hardware) and a 10 on the other side(software) or vice versa.One side can be stronger than the other, but ultimetely you need to have a balance of both, even though the software side is more important in the end.And yes, people mostly bought(at least early on) because of Zelda.Just look at the insane attach rate for BOTW on Switch in march for proof.If people just wanted the hardware that wouldnt happen.You are subestimmating the appeal that BOTW had and has.
|
No, I think it still would have surpassed Nintendo's expectations, just not by as much.
My comparison isn't wrong. I'm 100% sure that if the PS4 launched with only 5-10 games like the Switch, it would have sold just as well. People weren't buying the PS4 at launch to buy new games, because new games weren't there. At least not ones that couldn't already be played on the PS3. People bought it because PS4 was a major leap in console tech, and people wanted to have it first.
No one's arguing that Zelda isn't a desirable game or that it didn't help, it's just doesn't make sense to think that Zelda was the Switch's saving grace. It wasn't. The Switch was very desirable tech on it's own. I'm not saying it would have sold with no games, but it definitely didn't need a game as prestigious as Zelda to sell exeptionally. Zelda was merely something to play on new hardware. A big something, but not the reason to buy it. The big launch exclusive on PS4 was Killzone. Switch could have had anything on that level of popularity, and it would have still sold exceptionally. Yoshi, Luigi's Mansion, F-Zero, Star Fox, Diddy Kong Racing, Donkey Kong. Pretty much any B-tier nintendo franchise would have done, as long as it wasn't a side scroller or top down.
The attach rate is literally just because it is clearly the only high calibar, masinstream game on the system. That's not proof that people bought the Switch for Zelda. It's just proof that Zelda was largly the only worthwhile game to get at launch.