Did you play it? What score would you give it?

I'm sure a few assholes will give this game a 60 or 70 a couple weeks from now.

P4  I don't know.

P4G 8.6

P5   9.2

Battle   P5 >>>>P4G

Story    P5>>>>>P4G

Character  P5 >> P4G 

Music  P5 = P4G

Oh yeah, forgot about DQ XI.That one also has potential.But other than that, I dont think those games will make this year, and I dont have a good vibe about Dissidia.I dont know, it dosent feel like its going to be as good as past entries.

Usgamer or Washington post, of course.

Didn't you know 70 is considered a great score now :P

Very nice scores, i don't like the highschool theme but i'll give it a try.

I know you're probably joking, but a lack of bad things doesn't necessarily make something a 10. The good things also have to be good enough. I can think of a few games that do nothing wrong, but i wouldn't give them a 10 because they don't do everything quite well enough to justify it.

It's possible they didn't give it a 10 because they already gave one out recently (i personally doubt it, but it's not impossible), but ultimately the difference between a 9.7 and a 10 from an individual reviewer is incredibly insignificant. 

I'm really glad to see my prediction was wrong! There's still plenty of time for the score to drop (or less likley, increase), but there's little doubt now it'll settle somewhere very high. I think Persona deserves a lot more success than it gets, and for better or worse people put a lot of value in metacritic. This is one of the rare occasions i'm actively happy to see something score well.

Not surprised that this game is reviewing so well. Congrats to Atlus for getting yet another super highly acclaimed game .  I hope it sells well in the West. Of course, I'm going to get it (though I had decided that waaaay before reviews came out).