By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Is This Misleading Marketing? (MS: GoW)

Off topic: the game looks very good.

People will complain but I don't mind linear type games with QTE and walking sections between fights because they give chances to flesh out story and see the environment you're immersed in. At least you can run through the walking sections which the order should have allowed.



l <---- Do you mean this glitch Gribble?  If not, I'll keep looking.  

 

 

 

 

I am on the other side of my sig....am I warm or cold?  

Marco....

Around the Network
ironmanDX said:
So, you want them to have, "Running on PC" right at the top or even in the video title? To find out it's running on PC only 1 click away... on the same page the video is on.



Perhaps S stands for straws.

 

lol, yes? It is actually common practice to disclose wich platform a game is running on.



Hunting Season is done...

NathObeaN said:
Lrdfancypants said:

I think it's just marketing and they do want to showcase their best footage but it is also something that gets called out on the interwebs when companies do it.  That's probably why you see those little sayings "footage captured from ______ or run in ingame engine on ______" or however they word it.

Rest assured if Sony shows their next big relase with 4k pc footage there will be instant threads and this one will be forgotten.

If the game is playable on PC at 4K, and the console version includes a PC version and that's what they state in the video then I have no issue with that. If the game is exclusive to a console and they advertise the game as 'here is console footage' which is actually PC footage, THAT is misleading and should be addressed. This thread however makes no sense to me if I am honest.

I don't have a problem with it.  I'm just pointing out if another big title does it there will be threads on it just as on this.

It is the cycle of gaming life.  I imagine there will be threads on other aspects of the game that were negatives for other games.  I personally didn't mind those "negatives" so I'll like this just as I like other games.



l <---- Do you mean this glitch Gribble?  If not, I'll keep looking.  

 

 

 

 

I am on the other side of my sig....am I warm or cold?  

Marco....

It's a bit misleading but nothing out of the ordinary, unfortunately. If I could decide, marketing like this (from anyone) would have consequences but unfortunately I'm not.

GribbleGrunger said:

To see it's actually running on a PC you have to hit 'see more'. How many people do that, let alone read the description below the video?

That's unfortunate but OK. I'd say it's the way YouTube splits longer descriptions into the part that's immediately visible and the part that's only visible once you click 'More'.



Lrdfancypants said:
LudicrousSpeed said:
I said Pewdiepie or however you spell it was in the wrong because he hid his disclaimer in that same section, but this is different because why the heck would people believe an Xbox is running Gears 4 at 4K? Meanwhile, you don't expect streamers to have their positive impressions bought and paid for.

Plus, I thought everyone has a great PC to play these MS games on now and they killed the console brand like 4 times already? I think a vast majority of people understand an Xbone won't be running Gears 4 at 4K in 2016. Sure, you can point to some comments about people being mislead, but they are YouTube comments. Might as well start citing Metacritic user scores as valid opinions.

Wouldn't both be wrong for doing the same thing if you think one is wrong?

 

If you want to strip away all context and motivation behind the two, then sure. But that's silly, and I didn't do that.

Around the Network
GribbleGrunger said:

It ends with an advert for the XB1s. I wouldn't call that straws. It's misleading, as some of the comments are now showing.

It is misleading because some commenters are too stupid to look in the description and also ignore that "Xbox" doesn't stand only for Microsoft's home consoles but also for their Windows games and the whole Xbox service?



foodfather said:
Not misleading the all. The grand daddy of 3rd person shooters is back baby. So expect more threads like this from the usual suspects.

It's very misleading. MS are one of the best at using shady tactics. It's not a pop at MS fans, it's just true.



Barozi said:
NathObeaN said:

As I said, Xbox is not a console, it's a service now. They are advertising the game for a service, not a console. If Playstation advertised a game for PS Now, my version of the game may look worse than yours due to internet connection and/or the device I am playing it on. Sony however, would of course demonstrate the game working on the best device with a flawless internet connection. That doesn't make it misleading because they are demonstrating the product I am purchasing. It's up to me what device I run it on.

Exactly. Of course it's on the Xbox channel, as it makes use of countless features of the Xbox PC app.
Be it achievements, cross play, streaming, party chat or whatever, you need the Xbox PC app.

At the very least, it's also still a console. An individual piece of hardware being sold by MS. And yes, this kind of crap is too common, has happened before, and will happen again. Everybody has done it. It's so common, that this very series has had a fairly strong association with this type of activity, dating back to the original. Killzone 2 has one of the more infamous "target render" E3 videos around. To me, the worst offender in history is the "Ultra" 64 pre-launch campaign of lies. The level of deception surrounding the lead-up to that system's launch was mental.  Still loved it in the end, and it slooowly started showing it's true colours as the launch neared, but the lies surrounding the exagerations of it's power were gross. Hope that makes sense. Been awake for 25 hours straight.



- "If you have the heart of a true winner, you can always get more pissed off than some other asshole."

SWORDF1SH said:

Because it starts off with the Xbox logo, has the Xbox logo on screen all the time and ends with an Xbox ad, yet they used PC footage. It's misleading!

Does it start with the "Xbox One logo"? Has the video the "Xbox One logo" on screen all the time? Is it on the "Xbox One YouTube channel"?



yes it is