Well I called it, literally 5 minutes ago.

"CD Projekt Red has, in a statement given to Eurogamer, confirmed The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Game of the Year Edition."

I'd say wait until the GOTY edition comes out for Witcher.

The Witcher 3 is a much better choice, its so big, so much to do!!! so much content, its insane and fun!

I haven't even played the witcher yet, but i bought a dlc pack off some random guy xD

The two are totally different games from one another and both are must play for what they get right do so well in their own right.

You essentially have possibly the best Western rpg (i preferred it to Fallout4 and Skyrim) and a collection of the best action adventure tps games.

I would say get uncharted collection, finish them, trade them in and get W3.

Uncharted collection takes about 12-15 hours per game if you play them once each. I usually play them twice. Once for the story and once again to get all the treasures and take in the scenery.

I beat Witcher 3 with most of the side quests completed by putting in about 70hrs. It is very much possible to put over 100 hours. My friend is totally hooked on Gwent.

If you want a game that will last you a long time, probably Witcher 3. If you want something shorter to move on to something else, Uncharted Collection.

The witcher 3 would be the better pick. I really liked the characters, dialog, quests and changeable tone of the game. The writing was really good. Makes other open world games seem bare or shallow in comparison. The romance in the game is more mature than what you'll experience in other games. With DLC, most of it is free except the two big expansions but they're worth getting.

Witcher 3 without a doubt

How is the romance compared to Dragon Age Inquisition?

The Witcher 3

I probably wouldn't. At that point I would be uncharted' out. lol