By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - eSports: a true sport or just videogaming?

 

eSports a true sport?

Yes 36 25.90%
 
No 74 53.24%
 
Some games yes, definitely. 12 8.63%
 
If Curling is a sport, an... 17 12.23%
 
Total:139
Uabit said:
Chess is a sport, so eSports are too. They require a lot of mental dedication and focus.

Chess is recognised as a sport because of certain criteria by the IOC. Some of these being that it was one singular governing body which regulates things. eSports does not and therefore is disorganised in certain areas. Chess is a single game, while eSports is 30 games wanting to be considered a single 'sport'. You cannot apply the same rules to say League of Legends as you can Street Fighter. In other words, each computer game which is to be considered a 'sport' should be considered individually. Have it's own governing body and have rules which the IOC might recognise.

Also the exertion of a 4 hour + Chess game has been mentioned as being more intense than a football game. A few 10 minute CoD matches do not compare.



Hmm, pie.

Around the Network

Competition? Yes.
Sports? No.
That's why it's well known as eSports or cybersports, because it isn't just a sports.



Ka-pi96 said:
vivster said:
The gull of some people devaluing other people's efforts just to make them feel better is appalling.

Agreed. Absolutely appalling that some people would claim to be an athlete when they're clearly not just to make them feel better about themselves. It's just so disrespectful of real athletes.

Define athlete then.

An athlete (American and British English) or sportsman (British English) is a person who competes in one or more sports that involvephysical strength, speed and/or endurance.

Tell me that you do not need physical speed and endurance as a pro gamer. Not to mention great hand eye coordination and skill.



If you demand respect or gratitude for your volunteer work, you're doing volunteering wrong.

greenmedic88 said:
The spectator thing and cheering and whatever doesn't make much of an argument for an activity being sports.

The same thing can be said for board games and collectible card games. I would have to resist the desire to engage in debate with anyone who wants to make an argument that Magic the Gathering or Monopoly or Words with Friends is a sport.

The things you mentioned aren't sports because of RNG. Things heavily reliant on RNG are not and should not be sports. That's why Hearthstone is not a sport but Starcraft and CS is.



If you demand respect or gratitude for your volunteer work, you're doing volunteering wrong.

I'd say "just video gaming", though I suppose it's the same category of sports as say chess is.



Around the Network

No. It's just video games.



Louie said:
From my experience with some friends who are heavily into that scene? Nope. Sport is about physical activity and being competitive on a physical level to me. eSports is just people sitting in front of a computer screen and talking into a headset. Being fit won't help you win an eSports game. (Same goes for chess, but I don't know why people consider chess to be a real sport either, even though I love playing it.)

One area that can be improved, by training/excersising. Is the speed you can button tap. You can pratice aiming, for FPS games.

Ka-pi96 said:
vivster said:

Define athlete then.

An athlete (American and British English) or sportsman (British English) is a person who competes in one or more sports that involvephysical strength, speed and/or endurance.

Tell me that you do not need physical speed and endurance as a pro gamer. Not to mention great hand eye coordination and skill.

And endurance? For playing games? So the same kind of endurance you'd need for a late night movie marathon? Yeah, nothing at all athletic about that kind of endurance...

What about speed runs? Completing a long game within a certain time? I wanted to clear the 100 Battle Tower in Pokemon Colesuem. I played the game for 14 hours non stop. To clear it in one day. That's edurance. I'd classfy it like Chess, a mind sport. Because If I wanted to complete a Pokedex within, say 100 hours. I'd have to know the games story mode. Inside and out. And how fast I can use older hardware/other games, that I need to transfer Pokemon like crazy. Without cheating.

I could actually do this. I own all the GB DS system hardware. And all the games that can link across, over the years. It take planning and pratice. To hit a certain time peroid. Just like a sport. What about the blind guy. Who cleared Zelda OOT? That took a lot of pratice. Would people go nuts, if say, the olymipics added in eating contests?



Not going to argue with anyone here as my interest for the topic is little to none besides this passing comment. But I consider it a type of sport. Obviously not the outdoors/physical sports but more align the lines of chess. I'm not saying it should be put in the same category as chess either, I'm just pointing put the variations that exist within the word itself. I believe the term can refer to video games as well. I think others here may have a more narrow definition on what they consider sports



I've been playing video games since I was 5 years old with people twice my age at that time. So no, I really do not consider it a sport, and I've been playing sports like baseball, football, Cricket, Street hockey around that age too. There is a difference.



Is chess a true sport or just a non-electronic game?



I LOVE ICELAND!