Whoa, I just got serious VGChartz deja vu...

I'll throw my analysis in the ring, too:

Phil's tribute to shooting victims - seemed heartfelt, nice gesture
Gears - graphics and mechanics look sweet, worried a bit about scripted sequences
Killer Instinct/RAAM - sure, why not
Forza Horizon 3 - great graphics, great online, great gameplay
ReCore - gameplay didn't wow me
Final Fantasy XV - if the game plays like the demo, it's going to be lousy
Battlefield 1 - encore trailer, but still has promise
Minecraft - presentation started to drag at this point
Custom controllers - sure, why not
Inside - why are we still waiting on this game?
Limbo FREE - nice!
Indie sizzle reel - disappointing Cuphead and/or Below didn't get more screen time
We Happy Few - demo was overlong but provocative stuff
Gwent - after Hearthstone I believe a card game can be great
Tekken 7 - looks good! Harada is the man
Tekken Tag 2 FREE - nice!
Dead Rising 4 - looks OK
Scalebound - shaping up nicely. Love the combat and co-op options
Sea of Thieves - pleasantly shocked this looks so good. But how big is the world?
State of Decay - first game was a happy surprise, so keep 'em coming!
Halo Wars 2 - I'm a gameplay trailer man, but holy heck that was an awesome cinematic trailer
Halo Wars 2 beta - bring it on!
Project Scorpio - not interested

I'd give it a 7/10. Some interesting gameplay, but no surprises and some pacing problems in the middle.

I bolded the parts I would change, but yeah. I agree with you on most of this.

We Happy Few looks cool, Forza looks gorgeous as always. Nothing else did anything for me.

FFXV, I think I've made up my mind not to buy. I'll re-look at the game when it's out and people are playing, but that just lost any interest I had.

Scorpio, sounds cool and I am curious to learn more, particuarly pricing, but with pretty much everything shifting to Win 10 and some stuff on steam kinda redundant for me.

ReCore's trailer kinda got me hyped. Looks like it could be fun.

Lack of surprises killed the fun of the conference though. Also XBOX exclusives are dead, so that's kinda interesting.

The game is only 39.99$ so there is no reason to not go for it if your interested.

The downplay is strong in you.

How you word things in this post doesn't really make sense and is confusing.

And yet did I say anything wrong? All on PC, almost no new announcements, cool new Slim version but please wait next year for our awesome next console. What's wrong in this? That's their new strategy with PC gaming in mind, they just screwed up their Scorpio announcement by announcing it a year too early, wich kills the current XBox One (and sadly the Slim too) even faster than the PC focus does. A Scorpio announcement at E3 2017 would have been a lot better.

I feel like you, and others, look at the "all on PC" thing with far too hardcore of a video game players mindset.  The casual fan who plays an XB1, the majority of the people who play on it, are not giving even one shit about whether the games are available on PC or anywhere else.  Those of us who are on the boards, sure they are losing some sales perhaps with us.  The people who just walk into Target to buy themselves/their kids the latest system their friends have, nope.

Agreed Who cares you get more value with your game now and cross play on multiplayer means that games will be supported more. It's a win win wether you buy an MS game on PC you are still supporting Xbox at the end of the day.

They made a good conference from what they had, but I would've liked to see more of Cuphead and ReCore. However I'm a bit miffed by the lack of new game announcements.

7ish/10