MohammadBadir said:
LurkerJ said:
ou know what I want to die off? The term "moderate" Muslims.
There is no MODERATE Islam. Just like there is no moderate Christianity.
The only reason moderate Muslims are perceived as moderate is because they omit the parts of Islam that do not fit the 21st century. In other words, they are lazy Muslims who can't bring themselves to live by the holy book and hadith, and sometimes, they can't bring themselves to even read them.
Lazy is fine. Lazy Christians, who can't bring themselves to even read the bible, didn't stand in the way of moral progress. Muslims becoming lazy, when it comes to religion, is a good thing.
Let's call it as it is, no need for politically correct terms like "moderate Muslims". They are just lazy, and partially unconvinced of their own beliefs.
|
Lol what are you even talking about. The Quran is a book of context. You can't just read up a few verses and make conclusions. Over a millennium of Islamic scholarship concludes that the verses that are about fighting the infidels or whatever, which, by the way, mostly were spoken by Muhammad for the first time during battles in which Muslims' existence was at a threat, were only related to the battles they experienced and thus the conclusion was that they refer to Muslims fighting only when they're attacked, or when their property (mostly land) is stolen. You're right that there's no moderate Islam. That phrase in itself is offensive. Islam is Islam and you're either a Muslim who follows it right or are somebody who doesn't.
|
First of all, I don't think those verses are the only controversial verses found in the Quran, and you will be happy to know that those verses are not the ones that put me off Islam as a whole.
It's been a while since I read the Quran or the Bible, but here is one thing to entertain "Moderate" Muslims by; I can't think of a sin that warrents eternal punishment.
Believers do actually know what eternal punishment means, right?
1. Open a new empty notepad on your PC right now
2. Tap on number "1" once
3. Click and hold number "0" for an hour
Do you see that number in front of you? Well, that number is still much smaller than eternity.
Eternal hell is mentioned multiple times in the Quran. Allah has promised to punish some sinful humans by throwing them in hell for eternity.
I can't think of a single sin that warrents such punishment. You can rape newly-born babies for 60 years and I still wouldn't throw you in hell for 60 years, let alone eternity.
Kill by the millions, torture the weak, steal, burn animals with fire and I still wouldn't sentence you in hell for eternity. A punishment I can't possibly think of as moderate or just.
This whole "I am gonna make weak ignorant humans and test them, and punish them or reward them based on their actions" game Allah has created can nevere be seen as moderate under any light. Especially when Allah says: "We did indeed offer the trust (freedom of choice)to the heavens and the earth and the mountains, but they refused to bear it,and were afraid of it. But the human being accepted it; surely he is unjust,ignorant.". I don't ever remember accepting such a sick deal as a human in the first place. That's not what I think a moderate religion is. Making humans intentionally ignorant and punish some of them with eternal hell? Not moderate.
And let's pretend that there aren't wildy disturbing phrases about homosexuals, slavery, women and what should do just because they are women. Please don't tell me "you don't understand what these phrases really mean". Like it or not, Gay Arabs can't be openly gay in most Arabic countries and it's because of Islam and the Quran. Like it or not, there are entire fiqh books discuss slavery in Islam, how slaves should treated, the rights and the duties of the slaves under Sharia law.
I don't want dive deeper, I am largerly off-topic.
The point I want to make? Islam needs heavily twisted interpretation to look "moderate", and if those twisted interpretations lead to a better world, I am all for it. It happened (still happening?) to Christianity and the world has been better off since then, that doesn't make Christianity a moderate religion by any means.