RolStoppable said:
You have three flawed reasons that get increasingly worse.

1. TP HD has redone graphics as well as overhauled and new gameplay features. Zelda U will be more or less a straight port, so it doesn't demand as many resources. Additionally, resources aren't really wasted when you can sell significantly more hardware and software with the decision to port the game to NX. A successful system is also good for consumers because then there's no looming question of whether or not the next Zelda game needs to be delayed in order to be prepared for a new system.

The just updated the texures. And Zelda Wii U to NX will most likely be a PowerPC to X86 port, so in that case it will be more difficult then Twilight Princess HD (PowerPC to PowerPC)

2. If NX is a success, then the next Zelda will be on NX as well. 

I doubt that. The Wii was a success but skyward sword sold pretty bad. It sold worse then Splatoon.

 
3. You mean like the Wii couldn't compete with the GC's lineup? The Wii passed the GC's lifetime sales in 15 months.

The Gamecube lineup was better then the Wii Lineup at all imo.

Since I'll buy NX, it makes sense for me as customer to get Zelda U on NX, even though I have a Wii U.

In that case it wouldnt matter on which system you would get it. On the other hand, like I already mentioned, the next zelda will most likely be delayed because of the time they spend on the NX port. So this will even be a disadvantage for you in my opinion.

Yes, he wants that. Only that NX won't cost $400+.

Consider this:

- Porting takes time and ressources. Games like Twilight Princess HD tooked around 2 years to port (they started anytime in 2014). Zelda wii u port will most likely be done by the zelda team themself (they wont outsource such a project, no way). So the time they are using now on Zelda port, they could put directly into the next zelda. Result: Zelda Wii U on NX will delay the next zelda for around 1 year (because they will "waste" their time with an port)

- If they port Zelda Wii U to NX and the NX will be a success, they will probl do the same to the next zelda. Any Nintendo console will be started with an new Zelda game. So the next Zelda game would also be on the NX successor (5-6 year development time = console cycle). This means the nx (in terms of zelda games) will probl be very useless.

- Most of us own a Wii U anyway. So getting the game on the wii u is not a problem. For those who dont own a wii u, it will probl make much more sense to get a wii u for zelda at NX launch. Even with an strong lineup, NX wouldnt had any chance to compete with the Wii U´s current lineup. Also the wii u will probl drop in priece when NX releases. Keep in mind, you have Smash, mario kart, mario 3D world, Mario Maker, Bayonetta 2, Pokken Tournament, Star Fox Zero, Xenoblade X, Splatoon and much more on the wii u. Even with a strong lineup, the NX could never compete against that. It will probl take around 2 years till the NX will have an as good game lineup as the wii u currently have.

So even if it would make sense for nintendo to port the game (more sales, better NX sales), it wouldnt make sense for us custormers/nintendo fans.

Thats why I think they should find other ways to sell Zelda on Wii U and to sell the NX (other new games, third party support).

-TP HD is HD Remaster, not port. Zelda U probably won't be Remaster, it will be port. You also forget that WW HD development last only 6 months by Nintendo, TP HD was done by Tantalus much smaller team than Zelda team of Nintendo.

-I dont see like problem if NX Zelda being port on NX succor, nowadays every second games gets ported or remastered, especially because successor of NX will have same architecture and probably also unified platform, also from same reason I dont think next Zelda will took 5 years of devolpment.

-This dont make any sense. You forgetting that Wii U even with great lineup of games is selling terrible, but this year will sell much worse than previous. Ofcourse that people will buy new Nintendo platform instead dead platform, you basically saying that after PS4 launch most of people buying PS3 in order to play Last Of US instead PS4 but we all know that isnt true.

Also poll doesn't make much sense, because Zelda U NX port really wants only people who dont have Wii U, most of Wii U owners are fine with Zelda U port for NX while game still coming to Wii U.

RolStoppable said:

1. They changed quite a few more things, similar to what they did with The Wind Waker HD. Zelda U's porting job won't be incredibly difficult, and like I said, it will be or more less a 1:1 c

Nintendo never did something similar. They always had a "reason" to port a game. Doing this wouldnt be nintendo style. Also Porting from PowerPC to x86 is not that easy.  

http://www.destructoid.com/naughty-dog-porting-the-last-of-us-to-ps4-was-hell-275048.phtml

2. But Skyward Sword was only on the Wii and that's the point. You lost.onversion. The biggest differences that I expect are a different control scheme (no Gamepad) and 1080p@30fps vs. 720p@30fps.

You got it. Skyward Sword was only on the most successfull nintendo home console ever but failed nontheless. So if they decide to release zelda cross gen now, zelda nx have goood chances to be not "only on the nx".

3. Your opinion isn't a good rebuttal, to be honest.

2 Prime games, Double Dash, Smash, Sunshine, Windwaker and TP, 

And the Wii had Mario galaxy and successor to those games.

4. I'll gladly take all the games that come with a healthy platform as filler to tide me over until the next Zelda arrives.