By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Cloud Strife Vs. Shulk. Who Would Win??

 

Who would win?

Cloud 96 42.29%
 
Shulk 131 57.71%
 
Total:227
Thunderbird77 on 17 February 2016

Obviously shulk. Cloud wouldn't even be able to parry because shulk can cut anything if focusing. Even without that, there's the visions of future + monado arts.



Around the Network
Thunderbird77 on 17 February 2016
Vodacixi said:

If it's base Shulk (Monado I) Cloud stomps due to the Monado not being able to cut through people. If it's Monado II, Shulk wins after one hell of a battle due to premonition, speed and shield (although Cloud also has some chances of winning here due to Materia, superior sword skills and other things). If it's Shulk at his prime this wouldn't even be called a battle: Shulk does with Cloud whatever he wants to do without any possible resistance on Cloud's part. At certain part of Xenoblade, Shulk is an almost if not omnipotent being with absolute controll over anything and everything.

Shulk isn't like you described at the end of the game but it doesn't matter. After the first power up, shulk could make the monado bend to his will and cut through cloud and the buster sword with a single hit. Visions, monado arts, blade size of the monado... only add to it.



burninmylight on 17 February 2016
deskpro2k3 said:
bigtakilla said:

An Art doesn't strictly apply to physical or ether (magic/elemental). So you're assuming it would hurt Shulk is based on assumptions.

 

The proof is in wiki, and how the summoning works in the game, so based on that, It will destroy Shulk with one hit.

Gotta love your dedication to your guy.



Kennel83 on 17 February 2016
bigtakilla said:
Kennel83 said:
My vote goes for Shulk. Though if we were talking about who looks nicer in Smash, I would go for Cloud, his attacks look so cool.

If we're talking about Smash, you have to take into consideration Shulk is trying to smuggle in an elephant, lol. Dat bulge in his underwear. 

Hahaha oh God xD

Is that a valid reason? Then it would be like this: Cloud<Shulk<Michael Fassbender hahaha

 



exdeath on 17 February 2016
deskpro2k3 said:
JWeinCom said:

Sephiroth never had control of the universe.  If he did, he would have pretty much accomplished whatever he wanted in an instant.  The best thing he did was blow up a few planets, but that was more for show than anything.

Shulk on the other hand does have control of the universe.  If he wants a world without materia, no more materia.  If he wants a world without cloud, no more cloud.

 

When you can control the fabric of space and time then yes, Sephiroth control the universe. "The Promised Land" Which grants Sephiroth unlimited mako power is pretty much God power. He bestroyed some planets, and cause a Supernova just for show. Now imagine if he was serious. The only reason why he didn't accomplished his goals is because he enjoys tormenting Cloud. His arrogance is his only weakness.

Even if Shulk wanted no more materia or no more Cloud, there is still Aerith supporting Cloud to negate and undo any harm on Cloud. She has proven to do this in the movie Advent Children.

If you want to bring in outsiders and not let this be 1v1 we can bring in Alvis...

 

*poof* bye Cloud... bye Aerith.



Around the Network
Azzanation on 17 February 2016

Shulk becomes a god in his game. Cloud is good but Shulk is in another league if your comparing lore.



deskpro2k3 on 17 February 2016
exdeath said:
deskpro2k3 said:

 

When you can control the fabric of space and time then yes, Sephiroth control the universe. "The Promised Land" Which grants Sephiroth unlimited mako power is pretty much God power. He bestroyed some planets, and cause a Supernova just for show. Now imagine if he was serious. The only reason why he didn't accomplished his goals is because he enjoys tormenting Cloud. His arrogance is his only weakness.

Even if Shulk wanted no more materia or no more Cloud, there is still Aerith supporting Cloud to negate and undo any harm on Cloud. She has proven to do this in the movie Advent Children.

If you want to bring in outsiders and not let this be 1v1 we can bring in Alvis...

 

*poof* bye Cloud... bye Aerith.

 

Cait Sith, Game Over Limit Break = Automatic Win

Good bye everyone in Xenoblade Chronicles.

It is GAME OVER.

 

And don't forget about the All Lucky 7's. If Cloud HP is 7777 = Invincible Cloud



deskpro2k3 on 17 February 2016
padib said:
deskpro2k3 said:

 

Cait Sith, Game Over Limit Break = Automatic Win

-> Good bye everyone in Xenoblade Chronicles.

It is GAME OVER.

 

And don't forget about the All Lucky 7's. If Cloud HP is 7777 = Invincible Cloud

HAHA lmao, @arrow. that is so funny

What is even more hilarious is you laughing at hard facts.



deskpro2k3 on 17 February 2016
burninmylight said:
deskpro2k3 said:

 

The proof is in wiki, and how the summoning works in the game, so based on that, It will destroy Shulk with one hit.

Gotta love your dedication to your guy.

well you see it's more like my hard facts, against people dedication to Shulk.



Nuvendil on 17 February 2016
deskpro2k3 said:
exdeath said:

If you want to bring in outsiders and not let this be 1v1 we can bring in Alvis...

 

*poof* bye Cloud... bye Aerith.

 

Cait Sith, Game Over Limit Break = Automatic Win

Good bye everyone in Xenoblade Chronicles.

It is GAME OVER.

 

And don't forget about the All Lucky 7's. If Cloud HP is 7777 = Invincible Cloud

I believe he was referring to you constantly bringing up Aerith as Cloud's little helper.  Alvis is Shulk's help (and the Monado, it's complicated).  But Alvis trumps anything you care to list.  You cannot kill him, you cannot withstand him.  He is GOD.  There is no rule to let you beat him, cause he writes the freaking rules and changes them with a whim.  Trust me, it is in Cloud's interest for you not to try and trump Alvis :P

And you need to stop bouncing between comparing them via game rules and comparing them via lore.  Cause it's making the discussion a mess.