It general seems safer underestimating a score than over-estimating it. That's why you're leading Dulfite, at least for accuracy.

Update! New games added:

New scores used:

Kotastic takes the sole lead for total score and TheGoldenBoy and Captain_Yuri are tied at the top in accuracy!

Burek was awarded a penalty point for Fallout 4 and MTZehvor, Dulfite and Kyuu were awarded a penatly point for Rise of the Tomb Raider.

got close to TR & nailed fallout if they stay where they are

Update! New games added:

New scores used:

Captain_Yuri takes the sole lead for total score and Kotastic is at the top in accuracy!

Neoarc and gooch_destroyer were awarded a penalty point for Animal Crossing: Amiibo Festival and Mr.Playstation was awarded a penatly point for Star Wars Battlefront.

celador and Versus_Evil were awarded a bonus point for Rodea the Sky Soldier.

14 points for me, not that bad

34th on points but 17th on accuracy always that 1-2 away from getting them points :(

btw wouldn't the highest score for Fallout 4 currently be 88 on the Xbox One with 29 reviews. Rather than the 87 score it has on PS4

Hmm yeah maybe I should take the XBO but the PS4 has twice the reviews. But 29 reviews is still a good sample I guess. I'll wait a couple of days to see how it evolves and I might change it then.

I only mentioned it as I remeber somewhaere it was said the highest score is taken as long as there was a good enough sample, Anyway its one to keep an eye out on both platforms.

Tons of duds this year on Metacritic :(

Lots of bad user ratings

@Boutros
I am the only one who predicted Zelda correctly but didn't got a bonus point.
How can I get bonus points? xD