I pretty much only buy digital now, but if I were still going physical I would totally go the BB route. They're garbage for pretty much all electronics, but their video game setup and rewards are actually top notch.

I hate Gamestop so I never shop there. But it sounds like you're a Best buy employee

It's hard to not sound like a BB employee after getting a brand new PS4 game day one for close to half price. I switched my buying habits over in January, no regrets whatsoever.

The Gamer's Club Unlocked membership should really seal it for everyone. Literally pays for itself. If you think you'll buy 2-3 + games new, unused in the next 2 years it's certainly the way to go.

I used to buy from gamestop as well, but as soon as best buy started the gamer club thing, I started shopping there almost always. A new game with that card is usually cheaper than a used game at gamestop. The gamer club card is such a great deal. It's already paid for itself twice for me and I only got it recently.

Its hard to argue with the value of the program. The gamers club 20% discount means a new game only costs $48. That alone is valuable. My only issue is that the nearest Best Buy is over 120 miles from me. I plan on doing it eventually though. Its just a pain to go in person.

I would but I'm not sure if it would be as good in Canada. 

Well you also get 10% off on used games and if you buy 2 used games you get the third one free, for equal or lesser value of coarse.

I'm not, just can't believe I got a new game for 38 f'ing dollars, I should have done this a long time ago. ;P

eehh...if I'm pre-ordering a game I usually just go to Gamestop. Mostly just because I fucking HATE Bestbuy.

If I'm not pre-ordering I get games at work, because I pretty much never pay more than $45 on new games.