I remember and yeah they were and are comparable. TWD was nothing special though.

But ain't SSBU also a port/remaster of SSB 3DS? ;)

Yeah I am just thinking in regards to first party. Compared to MS and Sony, Nintendo appear to dominate metacritic. Then again, Nintendo don't cater for 3rd parties in the same way and most of the other high-scoring metacritic games are 3rd party.

And people act like critics are completely out of touch. That looks almost identical to most any "Best Games of All-Time" list, minus the pre-'96 titles. Nintendo really does put out the most consistently awesome games.

It is kind of confusing, but that is how Metacritic had it.

2012 - The Walking Dead: Season One (94)

Most overrated game of thIs decade.

Would 2012 GOTY not be Persona or Mass effect 3? The least reviewed version of the walking dead got a 94 but the versions it was mostly reviewed on only got 92 and 89 in comparison. Mass effect 3 should have walked away with the GOTY awards that year if not for the last 10 minutes of the game and the salt behind it. Should have still got GOTY that year even with those last 10 minutes but I guess publications couldn't grow a pair and go against the grain as people were quite upset with the ending so gave most of the awards to downloadable games barely worth a mention today.

The legend of Zelda just too strong though.

I added an edit to the the original post.

I have played all of those except for Super Mario Galaxy 2 and Grand Theft Auto V.

Mario and Zelda thrice. Slay, Nintendo!