Until Dawn, Uncharted Collection, Tearaway Unfolded, Everybody's Gone to the Rapture, Rime and No Mans Sky. all of which are said to be 2015 titles. 

NIce but mass market is who will be buying consoles.

Batman StarWars COD ACreed Hitmen is what will do the real sales damage. 

I was waiting for a list like this, thanks : ) These are some good games, but feels a bit lacking IMO. I felt The Last Guardian would have fit right in there, but it's 2016. Hopefully that comes sooner than later.

well Uncharted was delayed, and i think third party games make up for that this holiday. CoD, battlefront, mad max, Fallout 4, Rainbow six siege, Just Cause, Assassins Creed are all there. its just a few months wait for Uncharted, Street Fighter and Ratchet and Clank after all. 

I understand there are still great games are still coming the rest of the year, but most of those are multiplat games. It sort of loses that edge they have when they can be gotten else where. I don't mean to sound I am knocking down some of these games, but the exclusives they do have don't really seem that big either, to be honest. Sony will be plenty fine for the rest of the year, but I guess I was expecting something to go in there as well. That's just me though.

i wasnt expecting, but i was hoping for a 2015 western exclusive to be announced at E3. dont get me wrong, i am not saying their holiday lineup is that impressive. its OK, and yeah i agree its still missing that edge. but to me it isnt really that big of a deal. because there is A LOT coming in 2016 exclusive wise to make up for it. Horizon and Uncharted in the same year is just bonkers for me. 

Sony has A LOT going on, Dreams, Horizon, Uncharted, Street Fighter, Ratchet and Clank and TLG as well as many other studios making games like SSM (GoW), Bend (new IP), Quantic Dream and others. thats of course not counting the other timed exclusives they announced at E3. so honestly, as a PS4 owner i am not worried at all. 

Yeah, I wouldn't be either. There are plenty of games to be played, now and def next year. I don't mean to say there aren't. It's just that after the conference, I realized I didn't recall hear much about new exclusive games being launched for this year, which I found a bit odd. Usually sony has something planned for the holidays. It's not an issue though.

Third party games are huge and the PS4 gets the best versions of those games. So what has Sony to fear? Everyone who is buying a console for 3rd party titles like Fallout will get a PS4 this holiday.

Not sure if Sony is winning...
The Last Guardian looks nice, but is released somewhere in 2016.
The Shenmue III kickstarter says the game will be released by december 2017 (we'll see).
Final Fantasy VII Remake will launch in 2017.

Microsoft focussed on games coming out this holiday and at the beginning of 2016, and although I don't know what game it is: ReConnect looks really interesting. Also MS will have some cool stuff coming out in 2016 and 2017 as well, but they didn't show it yet. They took a whole other approach to this year's E3.

I think it's therefore difficult to say who won. It's like comparing apples and oranges. In the end, I can only say I was more excited during the Microsoft conference, and for someone growing up with Sony consoles that's saying a lot. I love the fact that Shenmue III is coming, but I can hardly remember how the second one ended when I played it on the OG Xbox back in the day. Don't get me wrong: I WILL play that game, but December 2017 seems such a long time away. Also FFVII is one of my favorite games of all time, but do I want to play it yet another time? I'm not really sure... I also played Grim Fandango back in the day, and while the announcement last E3 got me excited again, in the end, I actually didn't feel like playing the game again. I love the romantic memories I have of these games.

All I know is that, for now, the only next gen console that is giving me games I really WANT to play is WiiU. Yes, I'm excited as hell for Fallout 4, but will probably wait for the GOTY (polished) experience. I only just started playing New Vegas, so I can wait. And unless Square Enix confirms that FFXV will be coming out this year still, I see no need to jump on the PS4 or XBO bandwagon yet. I'll just be playing Persona 5 on my PS3, the new Tomb Raider on my X360, and Xenoblade X on my WiiU.

OP, I think Sony it made it clear that despite the fact that the year will be sparse with AAA's for them (yielding that battle to Microsoft). Their E3 has shown that they pretty much won the war....which spans longer then 2015. MS is going to have to dig down deep to beat Sony on the years that all of those games launch with I would wager to guess would be between 2016-2017.