9.

Gears looked great.
Backwards compatibility FTW. I'm hoping they add Stick of Truth and Fractured But Whole.
Halo 5 War zone looked great.
Cuphead.
RareReplay has Battletoads, Blast Corps, RC Pro Am AND Jet Force Gemini. Fuck yeah.
Tomb Raider looked like good scripted fun like Uncharted only a less exciting segment.
Gears beta. I played a couple hours today, amazing.
Preview program. Early access on consoles. Awesome.

I'm probably forgetting something.

The bad... ReCore was just a trailer. Forza 6 junk with the great grandson of that car dude. Pricey ass new controller.

Fallout mods! That's what I forgot. Is this in both console versions? I would assume so.

7/10

I'll just repost what I said in the E3 thread

+ Rare Collection
+ New Controller
+ backwards compatible with 360 games
+ Tomb Raider
+ Halo 5
+ Recore

- Rare's new game (art style aside it looked meh)
- Multiplats
- Indies (I love indies... but not at E3)
- Fable Legends.... stop showing this game