I can't predict how critics are going to respond to each game, I do think both are going to score in the same range (within 5% of each other).

I'm not an Uncharted fan, only 2 was a very good experience.

UC2 >/= Tomb Raider > UC3 > UC1.

I have doubts about UC4 even after loving TLoU, just don't love the series. I'm a lot more confident about the new TR because the reboot was such an excellent foundation to build upon.

Look at the bright side, PlayStation fans get to enjoy both around the same time next year.

Tomb Raider had no chance against The Last of Us.

Actually TLOU became the most awarded game in history the same year Tomb Raider was eclipsed.

Rise of the Tomb Raider won't have a chance against Uncharted 4. Both will be amazing games, but only one of them will be epic.