Somebody here recommended Oxenfree, I don't remember who it was but thank you! I didn't know anything about this game and I've now completed it twice. On my first playthrough I was a total bitch and felt bad about the outcome so I played a nicer character. This is what I love about games, they can tell the same story with different narration and offer a different experience. And what a story it was!
I only need one achievement for completing the game without saying anything. There's this new game + mode to continue timeline which for some reason didn't work for my previous playthrough. And I wouldn't want to waste NG+ by playing as a mute. Well, got to find time to finish it two more times I guess..