Done! Good idea. Included some other options. If I forgot some important games, please remind me and I'll add them. xD

From my experiences, I'd say Bloodborne.

Did not buy any (new) games this year so far so can't really tell.
But I think between Splatoon & Bloodborne....though I don't expect either to get GOTY.

Bloodborne or Splatoon.

I haven't got one so far, but maybe splatoon or x will fill that spot?

I have yet to beat it, but im gonna go with Bloodborne. Any owner of the PS4 should at least try to join the hunters. =)

Mine, so far, is Ori and the Blind Forest.

But I haven't played The Witcher 3, Bloodborne, or Splatoon yet. So this might change once I've played those or when other games like Batman Arkham Knight, Xenoblade Chronicles X, Star Fox, Quantum Break, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain, and probably other titles finally come out.

But yeah, I think Ori is an amazing new IP for Microsoft and I'm hoping a sequel is already being made.

Biggest contenders this year are witcher 3, bloodborne, and MGSV

Bloodborne.

haven't really played any of those in the poll so nothing is really GOTY for me yet, maybe Splatoon later but this year might also be the year where I won't see any being GOTY.