cycycychris said:
curl-6 said:
Meh, I still reckon TPHD looks better. :P
|
TP HD looks pretty bad imo. I don't blame Tantalus since I think they did just what Nintendo requested. But so many corners were cut in that remaster that it was appalling. It would be hard to make that game look great, but Nintendo certainly didn't try. They sure as hell put all efforts to make Wind Waker to look as good as they could possibly make it. And they reached that goal, even if it was not as laber difficult as TP HD would be.
|
I think TPHD was fine enough. Some great texture work and minor improvements that make it look far superior to the Wii version. For me, TPHD looks like a Twilight Princess from another dimension. Like if in some alternate reality the Wii had been an HD traditional console and Twilight Princess had been cross gen, Twilight Princess HD is almost exactly how I would imagine that would look. And I'm not sure how much of it is corners cut vs the engine just straight up couldn't handle it. It was a remaster, not a remake.
And Wind Waker HD is nice and all but all they really did was sharpen some textures and toss in some fancy tech. There are still some parts in Wind Waker that look almost N64 ish, a major flaw of the original that they didn't fix with even minor mesh edits or adds to make it look a bit better.
I think both are good remasters.