I want to say Metal Gear Solid V, but the metascores for MGS games always seem a bit screwed, the worst MGS game being rated the highest and the best the lowest.

Zelda U will with 95.

bloodborne

Zelda, it has to be.

I'm confused. What's funny about that?

I am going with MGS PP or batman AK

Zelda, Phantom Pain and Arkham Knight.

I actually think Batman: Arkham Knight will score higher than all of these games.

Batman: Arkham Knight - 93
The Legend of Zelda - 92
Bloodborne - 90
Uncharted 4 - 87
Halo 5 - 85
Forza Motorsport 6 - 83
The Rise of the Tomb Raider - 81
Quantum Break - 75
The Order 1886 - 75
Evolve - 71

Uncharted 4- Naughty Dog:

Their last 3 games have all been 90+.

Bloodborne- From Software:

Demon's Souls and Dark Souls both got a 89, so they might make it.

Halo 5- 343i:

Halo 4 and MCC are both mid 80s, so I wouldn't count on Halo 5 being a 90+ game either.

MGSV- Kojima:

None of the last 4 main MGS games has scored below a 90.

Evolve- Turtle Rock:

Their Left 4 Dead games scored 89, so they have the potential, but Evolve look like it could go either way...

Quantum Break- Remedy Entertainment:

They've never made a 90+ game, and the last time they came close was a decade and a half ago, so I wouldn't count on it.

The Order- Ready at Dawn:

This is their first console game, and their PSP games have scored from 84-91, so they could do it, but The Order doesn't look like it'll get a 90.

So personally I'd say...

For Sure: Uncharted 4, MGSV, TLOZ

Maybe: Bloodborne

Not likely: Halo 5, Evolve, The Order, Quantum Break

Uncharted 4 has as good a chance to pass 90 as Zelda, seeing as both franchises inhabit more-or-less the same part of the score spectrum. Uncharted 2 is above most Zeldas, Uncharted 1 is below most Zeldas, and Uncharted 3 is right in the middle of both the Uncharted and Zelda games.