By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Who has the better line up Xbox One or Wii U this Fall / holiday?

 

Which one?

Xbox one 123 22.82%
 
Wii U 415 76.99%
 
Total:538
celador on 13 October 2014
Maraccuda said:
celador said:
Wii U.

Project Spark has released with no fanfare, and the videos I have seen make it look really dull. We still don't know just how good Sunset Overdrive is. Insomniac are inconsistent (though I'd never say bad, the worse they produce is just average), and the game looks like it could be style over substance. The quality of FH2 and MCC isn't in question though, so the X1 lineup looks good right now, and could be great if Sunset Overdrive is a hit.

But I would still give it to Wii U. Bayonetta 2 has a meta of over 90, Smash is likely to be the same, and those two games are better than the X1 lineup, and neither are ports. Hyrule Warriors is decent as well.


Oh wow, it has released already? Definitely no fanfare for it, not even a squeak since I usually hear releases even for all those niche NIS games.


I was surprised when I found out too.  With something like D4 I understood the lack of advertising because it is such a niche game, but Project Spark has been given a pretty good amount of attention at the last two E3s and Gamescom so it is surprising how little coverage it has been given.



Around the Network
ktay95 on 13 October 2014
Maraccuda said:
celador said:
Wii U.

Project Spark has released with no fanfare, and the videos I have seen make it look really dull. We still don't know just how good Sunset Overdrive is. Insomniac are inconsistent (though I'd never say bad, the worse they produce is just average), and the game looks like it could be style over substance. The quality of FH2 and MCC isn't in question though, so the X1 lineup looks good right now, and could be great if Sunset Overdrive is a hit.

But I would still give it to Wii U. Bayonetta 2 has a meta of over 90, Smash is likely to be the same, and those two games are better than the X1 lineup, and neither are ports. Hyrule Warriors is decent as well.


Oh wow, it has released already? Definitely no fanfare for it, not even a squeak since I usually hear releases even for all those niche NIS games.

Yeah I was shopping online and saw it was out and was all like O_O When the fuck did that happen??

Havent heard a word about it since the Conker reveal at E3



Maraccuda on 13 October 2014
celador said:
Maraccuda said:

Oh wow, it has released already? Definitely no fanfare for it, not even a squeak since I usually hear releases even for all those niche NIS games.


I was surprised when I found out too.  With something like D4 I understood the lack of advertising because it is such a niche game, but Project Spark has been given a pretty good amount of attention at the last two E3s and Gamescom so it is surprising how little coverage it has been given.

Poor D4, deserved some kind of fanfare. Instead 'hey all, it's releasing next week'.

Wasnt Project Spark originally going to be a launch title? Atleast that is what I thought. But yeah the E3s definitely showcased it quite a bit, youd think MS would make more of a big deal out of it.



Australian Gamer (add me if you like)               
NNID: Maraccuda              
PS Network: Maraccuda           

 

DerNebel on 13 October 2014
celador said:
Maraccuda said:
celador said:
Wii U.

Project Spark has released with no fanfare, and the videos I have seen make it look really dull. We still don't know just how good Sunset Overdrive is. Insomniac are inconsistent (though I'd never say bad, the worse they produce is just average), and the game looks like it could be style over substance. The quality of FH2 and MCC isn't in question though, so the X1 lineup looks good right now, and could be great if Sunset Overdrive is a hit.

But I would still give it to Wii U. Bayonetta 2 has a meta of over 90, Smash is likely to be the same, and those two games are better than the X1 lineup, and neither are ports. Hyrule Warriors is decent as well.


Oh wow, it has released already? Definitely no fanfare for it, not even a squeak since I usually hear releases even for all those niche NIS games.


I was surprised when I found out too.  With something like D4 I understood the lack of advertising because it is such a niche game, but Project Spark has been given a pretty good amount of attention at the last two E3s and Gamescom so it is surprising how little coverage it has been given.

I saw a Giant Bomb first look on the game and it looked like it had an absolutely horrible model, full of microtransaction to unlock certain building parts or whatever you want to call them which otherwise seem to be very grindy to get. Seems mindboggingly stupid to me to build a game around creating your own content in such a way.

Here's the link, if anyone's interested: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8iBOEfmPfbk



SubiyaCryolite on 13 October 2014

If you care about 3rd party multiplatform titles (Unity, Crew, Far Cry 4, Dragon Age, GTA V, PCars) and don't want to get them on PC then the XBox One is the obvious choice. If its about exclusives make a choice on which you prefer. I'd rate them equal it all comes down to preference and future prospects, don't fall for buzzwords.



I predict that the Wii U will sell a total of 18 million units in its lifetime. 

The NX will be a 900p machine

Around the Network
dasert on 13 October 2014

So to sum up your post, you have NO clue about Project Spark or how it works but decided to post something negative about it anyway..



toastboy44562 on 13 October 2014

Xbox one obviously is better. But then of course its not fair because xb1 has so many more games



TheWPCTraveler on 13 October 2014

I'm inclined to give it to XBOne. Even when we only consider exclusives*, I'd still give it to XBOne. (Like it or not, Halo:MCC is effectively 4 and a half games plus online for all of them is a fantastic deal for $60, and I'd purchase an XBone for that if I had more cash to blow. I'd buy an XBOne for Halo:MCC.)

*Game on XBOne, but not on Wii U

But, screw that! Bayonetta 2 hype train, here we come! (Not as hyped for Smash, but I'm sure as hell hyped for Captain Toad, HyWa and Bayo2.)



 
I WON A BET AGAINST AZUREN! WOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

:3

mcronesixteen on 13 October 2014

I would say Wii U by far



Consoles owned: Wii U wii gamecube DS DS lite DSi 3DS Xbox 360 Gameboy Gameboy color Gameboy advance Gameboy Advance sp Gameboy micro and PC. 

dyremose on 13 October 2014

That depends on whether we are counting 3rd party games that is on both ps4 and xb1 but not on wii u as exclusives.. If that is the case then xb1 wins. If not t hen wii u has the better lineup