By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

Also, work.

Wont be on in a meaningful way for a few hours.



                            

Around the Network

To seen more town and meta gaming. Plus it's not like they'll come I'm and say you're a liar.

I'll be off for quite a while myself. It's a little past midnight here and while I'm usually up until 2 grinding in ni no kuni was putting me to sleep.



Hello guys, yes I'm still here. I know some people noticed a decrease in activity from my part and I certainly won't deny it. I'm not ashamed or embarassed by it since I think I accomplished a lot toDay, (analyzing the lynch result of yesterDay, mounting a case against Sparks, re-reading and providing input on padib, prof and radish). I've taken a more laid back approach to this second part of the Day in part because I had exhausted what I had to say and also because I wanted to observe for a while.

So some points I want to bring forward:

- Right now, the interaction between Khan and White make me believe they are both town. 

- Wonk's push toward a Carl lynch reeks of scum. Not because I'm overly confident Carl is town (he's more neutral for me right now) but because I feel it's an effort to stop Sparks from getting lynched.

- I still firmly believe Sparks is scum, his lazy claim certainly didn't help his case. And with Wonk's recent move, Sparks's flip will be quite revealing about Wonk's alignment.

Vote: Sparks

theprof00 said:
Regarding the trucks imp prof voting block, i irc trucks actually didnt suspect Astor at all and thought it was a bad lynch. Can anyone point to where he changed his mind?

I wouldn't mind seeing more pressure on carl but im not moving my vote from sparks. Im pretty confident sparks is scum.

You're right that I wasn't convinced Astro was scum. At the end of Day One, the votes were placed in a way that either Nickels, White or Astro would get lynched. I voted Astro because he was the one I thought least likely to be town.



Signature goes here!

Watching the votes carefully now. I have my own theory that i'd like to test.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Carl2291 said:
@Wonk

I did recieve a warning pm from WoW, can even ask him or Smeags if you dont believe me.

And if you think my general play of looking for slips, inconsistencies and contradictions makes me look like Scum, then I am sorry, but thats just the way I play.

And one more time, he DIRECTLY asked if he was a Medic. Medic is a SC unit that heals, aka a probable Doctor role (That or a medivac).


You keep putting me out of context and not understanding (on purpose perhaps?) what I'm trying to say or ask. This screams scum to me a ton.



Around the Network

Not really sure what to make of Carl and Wonk now. He seems to be going after White even whilst a good number of people have eased off. He "fell into Impertinance's trap" also, but I feel like he's being targeted a little.

It wouldn't surprise me if some Mafia are trying to deflect suspicion onto Carl, which is what Wonk seems to be doing pretty hard. WEPL seems to have voted just out of frustration, which I understand to an extent. But, I dunno. It all seems rather unusual; "forced" almost. Will be keeping a close eye on both Carl and Wonk (and to a lesser extent WEPL and Khan [but this theory sounds interesting!]) from here.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Conegamer said:
Not really sure what to make of Carl and Wonk now. He seems to be going after White even whilst a good number of people have eased off. He "fell into Impertinance's trap" also, but I feel like he's being targeted a little.

It wouldn't surprise me if some Mafia are trying to deflect suspicion onto Carl, which is what Wonk seems to be doing pretty hard. WEPL seems to have voted just out of frustration, which I understand to an extent. But, I dunno. It all seems rather unusual; "forced" almost. Will be keeping a close eye on both Carl and Wonk (and to a lesser extent WEPL and Khan [but this theory sounds interesting!]) from here.


I don't exactly believe Imp's trap thing.



Seems we've got a game full of people with the watch and wait attitude. I don't like it at all. Most the vets are to quiet.

TOS attitude has taken him off my list of must trusted. He's used the extra time to be a lurking like scum and only come back in to stop a decent investigation. Need I remind you we need to find more than just a team if scum? Not only that I fully expect him to come after me regardless of how sparks flips.

Day two is pretty much dead to me. I have more reads on people, but I don't think we'll get more out of Carl now. Maybe Padib will come in one last time before we lynch sparks.



Wonktonodi said:
Seems we've got a game full of people with the watch and wait attitude. I don't like it at all. Most the vets are to quiet.

TOS attitude has taken him off my list of must trusted. He's used the extra time to be a lurking like scum and only come back in to stop a decent investigation. Need I remind you we need to find more than just a team if scum? Not only that I fully expect him to come after me regardless of how sparks flips.

Day two is pretty much dead to me. I have more reads on people, but I don't think we'll get more out of Carl now. Maybe Padib will come in one last time before we lynch sparks.

I don't mind an investigation on Carl,  but there's a part of your vote post that rubbed me the wrong way and that triggered my scum detector.

Wonktonodi said:

Carl though is something else. He can make decent case with the words that white has used, but between how he did that yesterday with Nick, and his putting sparks at L1 so early, I don't see that my vote can be anywhere else.

Unvote 
Vote Carl


You put forward two reasons, one of which is pretty solid (the L-1 vote), the other, I personally find weak but somehow in your mind that trumps the case against Sparks and now you "don't see that [your] vote can be anywhere else". What I see from this is you backing out of the Sparks lynch toDay and trying to push for a Carl lynch instead even though his case is much weaker. Something doesn't compute here if you're town.



Signature goes here!

TruckOSaurus said:

....

You put forward two reasons, one of which is pretty solid (the L-1 vote), the other, I personally find weak but somehow in your mind that trumps the case against Sparks and now you "don't see that [your] vote can be anywhere else". What I see from this is you backing out of the Sparks lynch toDay and trying to push for a Carl lynch instead even though his case is much weaker. Something doesn't compute here if you're town.


Are you saying you are content with lynching sparks today and be done with it? I find this post puzzling. So far the only thing we have achieved toDay is to greatly increase the suspicion on Carl and that is only possible because we barely escaped a quick hammer on Sparks. Seems like a lot of people are happy to just let this day be a wash that ends with Sparks lynched.

The case against Sparks is strong, and in a large part that is thanks to your case against him, but I feel the case on Carl is getting very solid also. It is concerning to me that you seem to be happy to just dismiss that line of reasoning all together and in fact try to imply that looking for other possible lynches is not town friendly. It makes me wonder if you have set up a mis-lynch and are hoping for town to run with your strong case and now you're sitting back to distance yourself from the flip.