By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - When will PS4 reach 10 million sold? - ioi comments on undertracking

overman1 said:
Rab said:
COX said:
Rab said:
COX said:

sony knows how much they shipped. shipped =/= sold to consumers.

Sony was clear enough "sold through to consumers "  Are you saying that Sony are liars ?


They have been known to bend/spin the truth when it suits them 

I don't remeber Sony lying about numbers. There's a huge difference between don't be clear about numbers like during the Ps3 gen and lying. I guess that you have a source for a such accusation. 

 

During the PS3 era they did misslead with shipped and sold, I remember them even saying sold to customers once before, and it was later revealed to be to retailers which they then claimed to be their "customers", they are trying so hard to explain themselves because they know what they lied in the past

Well the fact they have ldie may just mean they are lying now, although no one outside of Sony really knows

http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2007/01/6584/

http://www.crappyreviews.com/gaming-news-and-notes/shame-on-sony-for-lying-to-consumers

Dude seriously...lol

stop citing Crap Gamer, it does not help your case...


I dont care, what they said on those sites did happen, this was just to remind you, if you have fogotten do some research on your own 



Around the Network
overman1 said:

Dude seriously...lol

stop citing Crap Gamer, it does not help your case...

This is one of the very reasons why many on this and other gamer centric websites, hate or say playstation gamers are the worst.

What is ironic is the gamers saying that are more obsessed with Sony and Playstation gamers than many playstation gamers are of them!

Its like how Sheldon cooper kept dwelling on how will , while will told sheldon "im living rent free right there"  

While pointing at sheldons fore head.



I AM BOLO

100% lover "nothing else matter's" after that...

ps:

Proud psOne/2/3/p owner.  I survived Aplcalyps3 and all I got was this lousy Signature.

COX said:
Rab said:




They have been known to bend/spin the truth when it suits them 

http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2007/01/6584/

http://www.crappyreviews.com/gaming-news-and-notes/shame-on-sony-for-lying-to-consumers


Thanks for the links but I don't see nothing about Sony lying about their sales. BS about graphism and resolution a lot of compagnies like Ubisoft, Microsoft,EA have done that. However it's not the same thing that lying about official numbers if it was so easy Microfsoft wouldn't be stuck when they have to talk about Xone sales.  

True a lot do lie, and Sony lies, they have a history of lying when it suits, I know they have misslead with sales in the past, I am frankly surprised people are trying to defend them in this area

I wont do all the work for you guys, look for yoursleves, or just remember (I know people do) if you were around back in the early PS3 era



shikamaru317 said:
Dang, some of you guys really need to lay off ioi. If you think you can do a better job than him then go make your own website and give it a try, I bet you'll find it very hard to accurately track sales in the same regions that he's having trouble with.

We don't think we can do better than ioi, but we think Sony can.



 

The PS5 Exists. 


Rab said:
overman1 said:
Rab said:
COX said:

sony knows how much they shipped. shipped =/= sold to consumers.

Sony was clear enough "sold through to consumers "  Are you saying that Sony are liars ?


They have been known to bend/spin the truth when it suits them 

http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2007/01/6584/

http://www.crappyreviews.com/gaming-news-and-notes/shame-on-sony-for-lying-to-consumers



I can never take you seriously when you got your citation from the EXTREMELY biased Xbox Fan  Numero Uno Crap Gamer.

Lol That dude hates Sony and loves Microsoft so much. He pisses Xbox green...


Just some examples, we all know it happened, so dont shoot the messenger 

really okay please take a look at his last 20 youtube videos on his  channel 



Around the Network
GribbleGrunger said:

We don't think we can do better than ioi, but we think Sony can.


LMAO, I did not say it, but I think certain 20 somthing of the gamers on the site were thinking that very same thing.

Right now we know that Sony is not being taken at their word right now for the numbers, which is fine and dandy. That also goes both ways also.



I AM BOLO

100% lover "nothing else matter's" after that...

ps:

Proud psOne/2/3/p owner.  I survived Aplcalyps3 and all I got was this lousy Signature.

ioi said:

I never said it was a fool-proof method, it is the ONLY way we have to estimate the sales in those regions. Have you ever seen a top 40 games in any of those countries or reports of sales milestones passed? Data is virtually impossible to collect from those countries for a number of reasons so the only chance we have to cover them is to examine user data and make some logical assumptions.

Let's get back to basics - all sales tracking works from the same basic principle - you get data for a sample of known size, figure out how that sample relates to the entire populus and extrapolate it to get an estimate.

Nobody knows exactly how many units of a video game product have been sold in a given region, never mind in the entire world! There are thousands of retailers and it is impossible (or cost ineffective) to collect data from them all. The "official" trackers like NPD (70%), Chart-Track (80%) and Media Create (40%) are basically guessing for the portion of their regions that they don't track directly and anyone who makes a global estimate is doing the same across regions - using data for known regions to extrapolate for regions that you don't have data for. If you can think of a better way of doing it then please let us all know!

Obviously, the methods used for VGC tracking and estimation sort of worked last gen, but are outdated this gen, if they are consitently over and under tracking. The formulas need to be reworked. 

Although, you don't have data for these 10 million sales, surely you have enough data from the last 10 months to revise the formula instead of simply adjusting to NPD or something.



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank

overman1 said:
Rab said:
overman1 said:
Rab said:
COX said:

sony knows how much they shipped. shipped =/= sold to consumers.

Sony was clear enough "sold through to consumers "  Are you saying that Sony are liars ?


They have been known to bend/spin the truth when it suits them 

http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2007/01/6584/

http://www.crappyreviews.com/gaming-news-and-notes/shame-on-sony-for-lying-to-consumers



I can never take you seriously when you got your citation from the EXTREMELY biased Xbox Fan  Numero Uno Crap Gamer.

Lol That dude hates Sony and loves Microsoft so much. He pisses Xbox green...


Just some examples, we all know it happened, so dont shoot the messenger 

really okay please take a look at his last 20 youtube videos on his  channel 

OK I get your point about that guy

Anyway this doesnt let Sony off the hook 

Look I've said enough, my point is made, I wish you a good day :)

 



Ka-pi96 said:

Except ioi's issue isn't the total that Sony have it is how they have come to that figure, where do all the sales come from? Sony haven't released a regional breakdown so he can't tell.


So ioi, does not know how Sony came to have those numbers? Like other tracking services do not know how Vgchartz came to know how Vgchartz comes by the numbers they have? Oh ' you don't say..lmao

Look, this is the point, Sony has estimated just like all tracking service's do.

And this idea that ioi is giving to say where is the discrepancy in the tracking numbers, is pretty ironic at this point because he does not know where these numbers are and it is Vgchartz claiming they can track world wide.

 

While that is a 3rd party company looking in.

Sony is a 1st party looking out at other's with the projections of numbers and saying no this was not shipped this was Sold through.

so that's why they made the point of this was sold through, not just only shipped to retail, this was sold through from retail to the consumer!



I AM BOLO

100% lover "nothing else matter's" after that...

ps:

Proud psOne/2/3/p owner.  I survived Aplcalyps3 and all I got was this lousy Signature.

You know, I have to say that I'm a little embarrassed by some users in this thread. VGC has never claimed to be 100% accurate, ioi has stated on multiple occasions that his methods are based on extrapolation and identifying trends, and now you are trying to suggest that Sony is blatantly lying about sales numbers because you take this console warz thing to heart and discredit their claim because of the discrepancy with this tracking and estimation site? That's a little shameful. 

Hell, we recently had a 1000+ post thread about a single user who stood by VGC numbers, despite numerous pieces of factual evidence that proved the contrary, not because he believed VGC charts had impeccable tracking, but because it aligned with his agenda as many of you are guilty.

ioi isn't saying Sony is lying, they are saying they don't have the data.

As for those asking for the remaining 600k to be simply slot in. That will patch the wound but it won't heal the sickness. The tracking VGC had for last gen is outdated this gen, and at the very least putting the numbers in the right place as opposed to slotting in "Rest of the World" will make the tracking a whole lot better, although I would prefer a full rewrite, but I'm a perfectionist.



In this day and age, with the Internet, ignorance is a choice! And they're still choosing Ignorance! - Dr. Filthy Frank