By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Fire Emblem Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

It wasn't an experiment hylian.
I promise you that pretending to be a power that is now vanilla is a typical scum tactic.
whether or not you believe me, thats up to you.
what matters right now is that were roughly three good reads up in this game against mafia.
myself, padib, outlaw
are likely all town, I cant speak for them but I know I am and you should too.
the more we can confirm, the tighter the noose feels around mafia.

I didnt go after sparks yesterday because I knew if I did, I'd probably just have another person push in my lynch. I kept an eye out for him and that is all. Now that im more comfortable, I feel I can go after him.
that doesn't mean im scum. Im town who saw the possibility of being mislynch if I made too many enemies.



Around the Network
Sparks said:
Well I don't know what to tell you, then. Obviously nothing I've said the past few hours, nor anything I will say will convince you. Reality is that it's a flimsy case.

If you want a slip, Trucks' apparent knowledge about daytalk was fishy imo. He didn't say he read it from WoW's post either, but instead backtracked and said he meant something else.

Tsk! Tsk! That's not nice going after somebody who isn't there to defend himself!

But I do like the consequences on you throwing suspicion at me. Seeing people suddenly remembering they were suspicious of me but that they can't be bothered to bring forward any real reason will provide some nice reading material for when I update my townie/scummy feelings.

You on the other hand did point to a real mistake of mine and since you did I'm going to address it with complete honesty:

I skimmed much of the posts where people were arguing about Day-Talk and thought people had agreed there was none so when I replied to Nickles I went ahead with that assumption. When you called me out on it, I didn't feel like telling you I was just a lazy ass and realized my wording didn't imply knowledge about Day-Talk and went with that.

Now, one more things about Day-Talk, I'm still considering that this game doesn't have Day-Talk mainly because Day-Talk for Mafia was introduced way after Words of Wisdom's time hosting/playing Mafia so it's not something I expect him to include in his game.



Signature goes here!

Padib
this is one of the last times I address you so better make sure the next times you accuse me its something important.
I expect you to play well, not god like.
im trying my best to find scum and all you are doing is undermining me. Half the time your accusations dont make sense to me. Like why I'd try to bus a fellow scum when there is clearly no suspicion on me. If I were scum I'd have nothing to prove right now. I could just sit back.
The other half of the time you're just calling me scum.

Its tough when im trying to build a case simply on what someone is posting, then u undermine me, the people im accusing then come after me (like khan and cone) and you can see how frustrating this is.

Im tired of arguing what i am to you. Im really starting to get the impression that you want me dead. And in my paranoid mind, thats telling me youre mafia. The last thing i want is for scum padib to win the game over me. If my pride gets in the way, ill probably try to lynch you, and it will probably be the wrong lynch. But i dont see any options here. As more vets get killed, your influence over the noobs will get stronger and stronger. Thats a problem to me because im playing as hard as i can and youre really getting in the way.just trust me. At this point i dont even know what to say. I feel like even if a cop scans me town youll still come after me. Im on the verge of quitting.I



theprof00 said:
It wasn't an experiment hylian.
I promise you that pretending to be a power that is now vanilla is a typical scum tactic.
whether or not you believe me, thats up to you.
what matters right now is that were roughly three good reads up in this game against mafia.
myself, padib, outlaw
are likely all town, I cant speak for them but I know I am and you should too.
the more we can confirm, the tighter the noose feels around mafia.

I didnt go after sparks yesterday because I knew if I did, I'd probably just have another person push in my lynch. I kept an eye out for him and that is all. Now that im more comfortable, I feel I can go after him.
that doesn't mean im scum. Im town who saw the possibility of being mislynch if I made too many enemies.


It was too an experiment, you just said so right afterwards in the same post. You claim you didn't think he was town and that you wanted to confirm with an experiment, using outlaw as the guinea pig. You say padib is likely town now, but you wouldn't be saying that if you hadn't had your way with that experiment. On the other hand, several other people were willing to believe padib, including myself and outlaw. You keep saying outlaw is confirmed because he was a coward, but that's the opposite of what you said yesterday, when you tried to get outlaw to vote for himself, saying that's what town would do because it would be a one-for-one trade of town to mafia, and as much as I hated the experiment because I believed padib's claim and didn't want his power wasted, I did have to admit that it made sense for outlaw to vote for himself by your logic. Outlaw's not voting for himself is a count against him, as you originally claimed. I still think he's town that just made a mistake there, but I don't see him as nearly confirmed as town as padib is right now. You on the other hand are contradicting yourself with outlaw. You voted for him with little reasoning, then didn't change the vote when momentum was winding down on him, forcing padib to use his power to save outlaw and reduce momentum further, which you in turn used as an excuse to stay on outlaw. Then today you say you think outlaw is innocent for the very reasons you claimed yesterday would support that he was guilty, and I think you're just doing so because people think he's innocent and you want to earn townie points by claiming his innocence too, but you want to do so without seeming like you're changing for no reason so you're coming up with a bullshit reason to switch.

 

And how the hell would going after Sparks yesterday have put you in danger? He almost got hammered yesterday! I was one of the only people pushing your lynch yesterday. If you'd given up with your stupid experiment, Sparks would have been lynched yesterday, and there'd have been no consequence for you. Unless of course you're on a team with him. But no, the reason you didn't go after Sparks yesterday was because you wanted to test padib's claim. If he's as stupid as you think he is, and you think it would be stupid for town to reveal what he revealed, you should have just trusted his claim, and gone after an actual lead yesterday, of which we had several. If you agreed with what several people said about his decision to reveal, namely that doing so was to ensure that he would get to keep his power, like myself, padib of course, and I believe Nickles and outlaw all did, then you'd have trusted his claim and gone after an actual lead. And don't give me that "it was our only chance to test it!" crap, because he claimed he'd keep his power, so we'd have a chance to test it later, when expending it would serve an actual purpose! You should have trusted padib, both based on logic and your own knowledge of how padib plays, but you didn't! And now, you're attacking him, because you're scared of him. You're attacking and creating confusion and paranoia, and it's pissed off several people, including myself, pabid, outlaw, and Cone. You don't seem to be thinking like a town either. You're using semantics, confusion, and paranoia to manipulate the battlefield and twist people's words to make them look guilty, rather than using logic and synergy to figure out who actually seems guilty.



Alright, I've had enough. We've gotten several good leads today, and they're all being ignored.

1. RCT- If he's lying, he's almost certainly mafia. If he's not lying, there's a decent chance he's mafia, and it would give us some serious solid information to go off of regardless of his alignment. Seems like a great bet for a lynch to me, but maybe not the best. Definitely high up there.

2. Cone- He seems to be telling the truth about being a doctor, and I'd be inclined to believe him anyway as we're both noobs and I can say that as a noob, I'd not have been able to come up with a lie like this without knowledge or research, of which Cone doesn't seem to have either, or at least didn't before he made his doctor claims. If he's a doctor, it seems unlikely that he's town, but not impossible. If he's a mafia doctor, he's relatively harmless. The only consequence is that town vigs should save their shots for now, unless they can fire in the day. So if he's a mafia, leaving him alive wouldn't hurt for now while we have better leads, while if he's town, having him around is good. Keep him in mind for later.

3. Sparks- I don't know about Sparks anymore. Prof made a good case for him, but now that I look back on it, it looks like he was doing anything he could to twist his words, and that maybe the case isn't so solid. My main suspicions for him were that he was buddying up with prof, and well...yeah. He'd be great to explore further in the future, but I'm not sure he's the best bet today.

4. Khan- Scummy posts. Little content. Starting to become more active and contribute more, but still a scummy vibe. Not enough to build a case to lynch yet, I don't think. The above three are better choices.

5. Wright- Same as Khan. Scummy posts. Little content. Starting to become more active and contribute more, but still a scummy vibe. Also not enough to build a case to lynch yet. Again, the first three are better choices.

6. Trucks- He gives a lot of people a scummy vibe, and as far as I'm concerned, he's been buddying with prof since he started playing, something prof himself seemed really excited about when he heard Trucks might be joining. He's been gone a while though, so it's hard to get a good read on him right now. He's a better choice than Wright or Khan, but not as good as the first three.

7. Prof- Lots of scummy tactics here. The way he plays just doesn't seem like he wants to help town, as much as he claims he does. His tactics consist of sewing fear, confusion, and doubt into the population as much as he can, and his favorite thing to do seems to be to use semantics to twist people's words to make them look guilty rather than use the logic he claims to be using and town synergy to figure out who actually seems guilty. Of the seven people listed, he's the most harmful to town. By lynching him and getting rid of his confusion, paranoia, and semantics, everyone will be less paranoid and confused and thus able to think clearer, and be more logical rather than rely on semantics, which as far as I'm concerned, have a worse than random chance of finding a mafia. Also, I still get the vibe that he's coordinating with people, though he's been trying harder to distance himself with everyone today, perhaps because multiple people called him out for this yesterday. I consider him the best lynch candidate for today.

 

My order for lynching:

1. Prof

2. RCT

3. Sparks

4. Cone

5. Trucks

6.  Khan

7. Wright

 

 

I vote theprof00



Around the Network

Padib
this is one of the last times I address you so better make sure the next times you accuse me its something important.
I expect you to play well, not god like.
im trying my best to find scum and all you are doing is undermining me. Half the time your accusations dont make sense to me. Like why I'd try to bus a fellow scum when there is clearly no suspicion on me. If I were scum I'd have nothing to prove right now. I could just sit back.
The other half of the time you're just calling me scum.

Its tough when im trying to build a case simply on what someone is posting, then u undermine me, the people im accusing then come after me (like khan and cone) and you can see how frustrating this is.

Im tired of arguing what i am to you. Im really starting to get the impression that you want me dead. And in my paranoid mind, thats telling me youre mafia. The last thing i want is for scum padib to win the game over me. If my pride gets in the way, ill probably try to lynch you, and it will probably be the wrong lynch. But i dont see any options here. As more vets get killed, your influence over the noobs will get stronger and stronger. Thats a problem to me because im playing as hard as i can and youre really getting in the way.just trust me. At this point i dont even know what to say. I feel like even if a cop scans me town youll still come after me. Im on the verge of quitting.I



Again with the double posting, prof...



I'd like to use game as proof that our time with day is way too long.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

outlawauron said:
I'd like to use game as proof that our time with day is way too long.


I am starting to think that after a certain point, more day time does as much to hurt town as it does to help it. At what point do you think that is? We get 7 days as of now, but I'm thinking maybe 5 days would be enough. We'd be making our closing arguments and final votes if that were the case.



Smh

There is literally no evidence against me whatsoever.
Id like these three lynched first when I flip thx. Cone khan hylian
do not let them try to change your minds.
cone khan hylian, oh and sparks too. Maybe sparks first.