By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Fire Emblem Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

Wright on 15 August 2014
TruckOSaurus said:
I guess I will launch into my own overarching theory since discussion might have moved on when I come back on Sunday.

My theory is that yes town has all those protective roles but that on the other hand the Mafia have a role cop (which would be Wright) and either a role thief or role killer (i.e. a way to cut our power down as the Days pass. In that way the unkillable combos we seem to have can be neutralized.


I'd like to hear what a role cop is.



Around the Network
Mr Khan on 15 August 2014
padib said:
There has been a lot of attitude changes since day 1.

I will begin.

TheProf suddenly considers Outlaw to be town after I played my skill. If my points on why Outlaw was town on day 1 were so bad, then why in the world would using my skill to protect him validate my points?? I believe theprof is mafia.

Sparks has gotten very careful day 2. Though it's a sparks meta I prefer, it makes me very uneasy with his change in play. I sense a facade. I sense mafia.

Cone doctor is a broken setup, as prof argued. I believe Cone is mafia.

RCT got mixed up with his fakeclaim. I believe he is mafia.

Wright, Khan and noname are worryingly quiet. I sense mafia. (Wright, this is your cue to pipe up about some town brainstorming, for example what is your opinion on the nightaction scenarios presented by prof and hylian)

Nickles' end of day switch off Sparks and his mention that he would have changed it anyways made me feel very uneasy. I sense piggybacking and I sense mafia.

My only town reads this far are Smeags, Hylian, Outlaw, Myself and the sacrificed Spurge.

Null reads are Trucks and WhiteEagle.

I believe there are two mafia factions and that is why town is 1) overpowered and 2) all over the place. (Mafia are not coordinated and seem to be accusing each other.)

So maybe 7 townies and 8 mafia to start?

It would definitely have to be multi-faction in that case.

I thought my level of "content" posting had gone up since day 2. It was day one i was mostly vague, now i'm starting to get the hang of things and a clearer picture of what's going on.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

theprof00 on 15 August 2014
TruckOSaurus said:
I guess I will launch into my own overarching theory since discussion might have moved on when I come back on Sunday.

My theory is that yes town has all those protective roles but that on the other hand the Mafia have a role cop (which would be Wright) and either a role thief or role killer (i.e. a way to cut our power down as the Days pass. In that way the unkillable combos we seem to have can be neutralized.

Well, I already said that there were possible roles to counter it.
Role thief/neutralizer is one of them.
Also strongman
Also ninja
Also roleblocker

But I see you noticed the same post I did, so townie points for you.



theprof00 on 15 August 2014
Wright said:
TruckOSaurus said:
I guess I will launch into my own overarching theory since discussion might have moved on when I come back on Sunday.

My theory is that yes town has all those protective roles but that on the other hand the Mafia have a role cop (which would be Wright) and either a role thief or role killer (i.e. a way to cut our power down as the Days pass. In that way the unkillable combos we seem to have can be neutralized.

I'd like to hear what a role cop is.

A role cop investigates someone at night and finds out what their role is.
Try not to out yourself this early in the game if you are a role cop, though.



Wright on 15 August 2014
theprof00 said:
Wright said:

I'd like to hear what a role cop is.

A role cop investigates someone at night and finds out what their role is.
Try not to out yourself this early in the game if you are a role cop, though.


Interesting...



Around the Network
outlawauron on 15 August 2014
Mr Khan said:
padib said:
There has been a lot of attitude changes since day 1.

I will begin.

TheProf suddenly considers Outlaw to be town after I played my skill. If my points on why Outlaw was town on day 1 were so bad, then why in the world would using my skill to protect him validate my points?? I believe theprof is mafia.

Sparks has gotten very careful day 2. Though it's a sparks meta I prefer, it makes me very uneasy with his change in play. I sense a facade. I sense mafia.

Cone doctor is a broken setup, as prof argued. I believe Cone is mafia.

RCT got mixed up with his fakeclaim. I believe he is mafia.

Wright, Khan and noname are worryingly quiet. I sense mafia. (Wright, this is your cue to pipe up about some town brainstorming, for example what is your opinion on the nightaction scenarios presented by prof and hylian)

Nickles' end of day switch off Sparks and his mention that he would have changed it anyways made me feel very uneasy. I sense piggybacking and I sense mafia.

My only town reads this far are Smeags, Hylian, Outlaw, Myself and the sacrificed Spurge.

Null reads are Trucks and WhiteEagle.

I believe there are two mafia factions and that is why town is 1) overpowered and 2) all over the place. (Mafia are not coordinated and seem to be accusing each other.)

So maybe 7 townies and 8 mafia to start?

It would definitely have to be multi-faction in that case.

I thought my level of "content" posting had gone up since day 2. It was day one i was mostly vague, now i'm starting to get the hang of things and a clearer picture of what's going on.

I don't think the game is quite setup like that. I also would take "sensing" to be nothing more than a FoS.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

Words Of Wisdom on 15 August 2014
Person Voting To Lynch Identity

Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5  
Conegamer RCTjunkie Wright        
HylianSwordsman ---          
Mr. Khan Conegamer          
Nicklesbe outlawauron          
noname2200 outlawauron          
outlawauron Smeags          
padib outlawauron Wright        
RCTjunkie ---          
Smeags outlawauron          
Sparks outlawauron          
theprof00 outlawauron          
TruckOSaurus outlawauron          
WhiteEaglePL ---          
Wright Conegamer          
spurgeonryan Conegamer --- --- --- --- Dozla
  With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.  

If the vote count is in error, please PM me!

Countdown to Night 2: http://itsalmo.st/#night2



TruckOSaurus on 15 August 2014

Conegamer voted for Wright on page 28@50ppp.



Signature goes here!

Smeags on 15 August 2014

Hey guys sorry for the absence. Double shifts and all that fun.

Should be on later tonight to go through everything and see what I can come up with.



3DS Rec Thread ~ Wii U Rec Thread ~ Xbox One Rec Thread

Mr Khan on 15 August 2014
outlawauron said:
Mr Khan said:
padib said:
There has been a lot of attitude changes since day 1.

I will begin.

TheProf suddenly considers Outlaw to be town after I played my skill. If my points on why Outlaw was town on day 1 were so bad, then why in the world would using my skill to protect him validate my points?? I believe theprof is mafia.

Sparks has gotten very careful day 2. Though it's a sparks meta I prefer, it makes me very uneasy with his change in play. I sense a facade. I sense mafia.

Cone doctor is a broken setup, as prof argued. I believe Cone is mafia.

RCT got mixed up with his fakeclaim. I believe he is mafia.

Wright, Khan and noname are worryingly quiet. I sense mafia. (Wright, this is your cue to pipe up about some town brainstorming, for example what is your opinion on the nightaction scenarios presented by prof and hylian)

Nickles' end of day switch off Sparks and his mention that he would have changed it anyways made me feel very uneasy. I sense piggybacking and I sense mafia.

My only town reads this far are Smeags, Hylian, Outlaw, Myself and the sacrificed Spurge.

Null reads are Trucks and WhiteEagle.

I believe there are two mafia factions and that is why town is 1) overpowered and 2) all over the place. (Mafia are not coordinated and seem to be accusing each other.)

So maybe 7 townies and 8 mafia to start?

It would definitely have to be multi-faction in that case.

I thought my level of "content" posting had gone up since day 2. It was day one i was mostly vague, now i'm starting to get the hang of things and a clearer picture of what's going on.

I don't think the game is quite setup like that. I also would take "sensing" to be nothing more than a FoS.

Shh, i was trying to ridicule his point for being oversuspicious of too many folks.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.