pokoko said:
LuckyTrouble said: You all want to know what the real AOTY is? Food Wars: Shokugeki no Soma. If another show manages to do as much right as that one did before this year is up, I will be amazed. Pacing was great, the characters were awesome, the mix of comedy and intensity focused around food was top notch. It surprised, amazed, and kept me hooked start to finish. It was a surprise hit that did so much right. |
Lameb! I dropped it around episode 15 or 16. I simply stopped caring. Another contrived conflict, another food-duel, another win pulled from the hind-quarters. It's Fairy Tail with grub. The main character was OP and annoying and the "school" made no sense at all. Why didn't those people go somewhere that actually taught them stuff? I can watch anime about sexy cats piloting magical mecha but this anime strained my suspension of disbelief past the breaking point.
Like it or not, Koufuku Graffiti is the superior food anime.
|
Oh hell nah. Imma take your complaints step by step.
1. Do we ever care when a school is entirely outlandish for anything else? Why care if this is just some hardcore chef school where you do more learning from other students than directly from the teachers? I didn't dig into Food Wars because I expected it to be a realistic representation of a cooking school. I mean, it's a shounen anime, not slice of life. Even then, they explain why people stayed at the school. By graduating from the school, you were basically designated a cooking god and could go anywhere you pleased to become a successful chef in whatever capacity you chose. There was a lot of incentive to surviving that hell.
2. I'm gonna have to spoiler some stuff here, but do recall that the MC is not perfectly victorious every time. The last one should be an actual spoiler for you, although I'm not sure what above it is a spoiler. You can just scroll through them to around the last thing you remember seeing if you don't want to be spoiled for the last third of the episodes.
At the start of the show, we see him immediately lose to his father in a food battle.
Getting into the school, despite what she really thinks, Erina still fails him. This just opens the door for a different trope, but he still technically lost.
In the Shokugeki against the professional chef, him and what's her face lost.
MC barely scrapes by during the hotel buffet breakfast challenge. Still trope-y, but not an absolute godly OP victory either.
In a Shokugeki versus his father in the dorm, he lost outright.
In the curry showdown, MC scores lower than the guy he was trying to beat, winning in one sense, but losing in what he was trying to do.
It was great seeing that although the MC was good, he still had a long way to go if he wanted to be great, with major stepping stones right in front of him that he couldn't immediately and magically overcome. He spends more time in what we see learning that he needs to improve more than we do seeing him sweep other people under the rug with his glorious and victorious skill. I mean, they emphasize the fact that the MC still has room to grow. Yeah, he's OP compared to amateurs, but he is still clearly outranked among the other student chefs.