By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Which RPG will do better Fire Emblem x Shin Megami Tensei or Xenoblade Chronicles X in sales?

 

Question in Title

Xenoblade Chronicles X 128 71.51%
 
Shin Megami Tensei x Fire Emblem 51 28.49%
 
Total:179
Mr Khan on 19 July 2014

Honestly concerned about the latter's existence at this point. Not a peep from E3



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Around the Network
siavm on 19 July 2014
Mr Khan said:
Honestly concerned about the latter's existence at this point. Not a peep from E3

During the presentation for project steam they said development was going fine for the game according to some articles. 



HylianSwordsman on 20 July 2014

XBC:X will win by default, since FExSMT is probably canceled :P



StarOcean on 20 July 2014
Clyde32 said:
StarOcean said:
I believe SMT X FE. But thats just me. I'm hoping it looks nicer than the new Xenoblade because that game is really ugly... could pass for a GameCube game :p


That game is beautiful. Look beyond the character models. Also, this is what the game would look like on the gamecube. Maybe worse.

I used this picture to show the contrast between characters and environments.

No matter what the game looks ugly to me XD it isn't pretty. It looks generic in my opinion. Don't take offense to what I say, but that's just what I think. Feel however you want about it, hell say it's the most beautiful realistic game you've ever seen if you want, I'm not stopping you! ... But yeah, no.. it's just... I've seen much better, so to me it looks really outdated, could've been accomplished on 6th Gen consoles... But hey, that's just me :p



Clyde32 on 20 July 2014
StarOcean said:

No matter what the game looks ugly to me XD it isn't pretty. It looks generic in my opinion. Don't take offense to what I say, but that's just what I think. Feel however you want about it, hell say it's the most beautiful realistic game you've ever seen if you want, I'm not stopping you! ... But yeah, no.. it's just... I've seen much better, so to me it looks really outdated, could've been accomplished on 6th Gen consoles... But hey, that's just me :p

 

You just missed the point... That is what the game would look like on the GC.



Around the Network
StarOcean on 20 July 2014
Clyde32 said:
StarOcean said:

No matter what the game looks ugly to me XD it isn't pretty. It looks generic in my opinion. Don't take offense to what I say, but that's just what I think. Feel however you want about it, hell say it's the most beautiful realistic game you've ever seen if you want, I'm not stopping you! ... But yeah, no.. it's just... I've seen much better, so to me it looks really outdated, could've been accomplished on 6th Gen consoles... But hey, that's just me :p

 

You just missed the point... That is what the game would look like on the GC.

I didn't miss the point. My point is that I don't feel it doesn't look good. You tried justifying your point by showing me the game if it were run on GC, didn't look much worse to me. You said it looked good before, I don't agree. Are we done here? 



DevilRising on 20 July 2014

Not really much of a question with this one, considering that Xenoblade all by itself sold more than most FE or SMT/Persona related games do. Plus, while FE and SMT fans are abuzz about what this game will be like (when we finally see something of it), but there is a lot of hype for "X".



DevilRising on 20 July 2014
HylianSwordsman said:
XBC:X will win by default, since FExSMT is probably canceled :P


When do Intelligent Systems or Atlus ever really show much of one of their games before finally unveiling it (in a fairly completed form)? They are usually mum for a long time. It's nothing unusual.



Clyde32 on 20 July 2014
StarOcean said:
Clyde32 said:

You just missed the point... That is what the game would look like on the GC.

I didn't miss the point. My point is that I don't feel it doesn't look good. You tried justifying your point by showing me the game if it were run on GC, didn't look much worse to me. You said it looked good before, I don't agree. Are we done here? 


I didn't finish my comparison. Sure the faces don't look good and you are entitled to your opinion, but I forgot to post one of the images.



StarOcean on 20 July 2014
Clyde32 said:
StarOcean said:
Clyde32 said:

You just missed the point... That is what the game would look like on the GC.

I didn't miss the point. My point is that I don't feel it doesn't look good. You tried justifying your point by showing me the game if it were run on GC, didn't look much worse to me. You said it looked good before, I don't agree. Are we done here? 


I didn't finish my comparison. Sure the faces don't look good and you are entitled to your opinion, but I forgot to post one of the images.

I'm not saying it's the worst thing the the world. The graphics are fine, but you took off from my main point which was I'm hoping SMT X FE look better. I have the feeling that Xenoblade X won't age well do to how they're styling it. 

I'm wanting the SMT X FE to be more stylized (maybe cel-shaded?) so it looks good longer. Understand where I'm coming from?